Friday, December 17, 2010

Georgia

The Georgia Charter Commission ponied up more money for virtual charter school students.
Five months after two virtual charters refused to open because of what they said was inadequate funding, and after a parents group launched several protests, the charter commission voted to increase the amount of money for each student Georgia student who attends an online charter school.
The commission said that virtual charters will receive $5,800 for each student instead of the $3,200 it originally allocated in late summer.The amount is still less than the $6,500 per pupil that the International Association for K-12 Online Learning (iNACOL) says states need to provide, but Georgia virtual charter school operators said they can work with the funding.
“What we just did is to bring Georgia’s educational system into the 21st century,” Ben Scafidi, chairman of the Georgia Charter Schools Commission told the Atlanta Journal-Constitution after the vote. “Come this fall Georgia will be a national leader in virtual education.”
Liberating Learning has contacted parents, advocates and commissioners involved in this issue and will post a more in-depth report in a few hours.

Monday, December 13, 2010

Georgia

The moment of truth for virtual school per pupil funding in Georgia may be at hand.
For more than six months, parents--represented by the Georgia Parents for Public Virtual Education--and the Georgia Charter Schools Commission have been at odds over how much money the state should allocated to virtual public school students.
A final decision may be made this week.
A little background.
In June, the charter schools commission approved the state's first virtual charter high schools, the Kaplan Academy of Georgia, for students in grades 4-12 and the Provost Academy of Georgia high school. Both schools were scheduled to open in fall 2010.
The commission also decided to allocate a little more than $3,000 per student. This was far below Georgia's $8,500 per pupil funding for students attending bricks-and-mortar schools. It was also below the $6,500 that the International Association of K-12 Online Learning (iNACOL) says is needed to provide an adequate foundation for virtual schools.
When the charter schools commission declined to revise its per pupil expenditure recommendation, officials at Kaplan and Provost decided that the necessary financial backing, they could not open their doors.
Virtual education advocates, let by the Georgia parents' group, asked that the commission review its decision. The Georgia Parents for Public Virtual Education also asked that a member of its group be seated on the on the commission.
The commission relented and agreed to review appoint a committee to review the funding decision. That committee recommended that Georgia spend about $5,800 per year for each student who takes classes online.
Georgia Families for Virtual Public Education President Renee Lord told pbaonline that more money would improve the quality of education for the state's six thousand cyber school students. "The schools will be able to lower class sizes, increase the amount technology in the hands of our students, and several other opportunities will be available to our students."
Lord added, the state should consider funding virtual students at the iNACOL recommendation of $6,500.
The charter schools commission is scheduled to meet on Dec. 16 and a vote on the funding issue is likely.

Friday, December 10, 2010

Louisiana

When the dust settled and the Louisiana Board of Elementary and Secondary Education approved the state's first virtual charter schools, it also allocated 90% of what the state spends on each Louisiana student in a Type 2 charter school to support students of the new virtual charters.
That's right, 90%.
"We wanted to give the schools the resources to be successful," Penny Dastugue, president of the Board of Elementary and Secondary Education (BESE) told Liberating Learning in an exclusive interview. "This is one more tool in order to make public education work for all of our students."
The two virtual charters approved are Baton Rouge-based Louisiana Connections Academy and the Louisiana Virtual Academy, which will be based in the New Orleans area. Both schools will serve student from throughout the state.
The Louisiana Connections Academy is slated to open in fall 2011 and serve approximately 500 students in grades K-12. Louisiana Virtual Academy, a K-10 school, is expected to serve about 1,100 students and also open in fall of 2011.
Louisiana spends about $4,825 for each student attending a Type 2 charter school, according to the Finance Department of the Louisiana Department of Education. The new virtual charters fall in this category.
While 90% of that figure makes a substantial statement of support, Matthew Wicks, a vice president of the International Association for K-12 Online Learning (iNACOL) says the BESE's funding decision is just one indication that "Louisiana is concerned about making sure that full-time virtual charter schools in the state provide a quality educational opportunity to the students."
"Providing adequate funding for full-time virtual schools is one part of having quality online programs, but it isn't the full picture. While BESE approved two virtual schools they also decided not to approve two schools because they had some concerns related to if the programs were prepared to offer quality programs. This isn't to say that the two schools not approved wouldn't be quality programs, but BESE is showing some reasonable caution in making sure that the virtual schools in the state will indeed be quality programs," Wicks wrote in an e-mail to Liberating Learning.
Wicks and Dastugue served on Louisiana's "Virtual Education Study Group" which looked at issues surrounding online education and at different funding models for virtual schools. Findings from the group's research formed the foundation of the BESE's final decision on the virtual charters.
"Louisiana is now the 28th state that will have multi-district full-time online schools. I would hope that if any of the 22 states that don't currently provide this option decide to establish policy to allow for full-time online schools that they take an approach similar to Louisiana by researching existing practice and seeing what works before making any decisions," Wicks wrote.

Thursday, December 9, 2010

Louisiana

It looks as if the Bayou State has its first virtual charter schools.
Two votes by a committee of the state's Board of Elementary and Secondary Education set the stage for approval of the two schools.
First up was committee approval of the Baton Rouge-based Louisiana Connections Academy. The virtual charter, which will serve students throughout the state, is slated to open in fall 2011 and serve approximately 500 students in grades K-12.
Next, the committee approved the Louisiana Virtual Academy, which will be based in the New Orleans area. This K-10 virtual charter will open in 2011 and is expected to serve about 1,100 students from across the state.
The full board is slated to review--and most likely approve--the two virtual charters.
New BESE President Penny Dastugue has promised Liberating Learning
an exclusive interview after the vote.
Stay tuned.

Wednesday, December 8, 2010

Wisconsin

Superintendent of Public Instruction Tony Evers said in a televised interview that he would accept moves to lift enrollment caps on the state's virtual schools.
During the 2010 campaign, Republican Governor-elect Scott Walker pledged to lift enrollment cap. His election, along with Republicans gaining control of both house of the Wisconsin legislature, made it appear that Walker & Co. would make good on his promise.
"I'm steeped in reality. I'm not sure if what I think makes a lot of difference," said Evers. "People have made clear what their positions are."
Opponents of exapnsion of online classes say there is no research supporting claims that virtual education improves learning environments.
Removing the caps on virtual schools or the choice program would not "fundamentally change the way those programs operate, nor will it dramatically increase the enrollments," Evers added. Julie Thompson, vice president of the Wisconsin Coalition of Virtual Families, said that the state's enrollment caps have limited accessibility to virtual classes.
Her organization called on state leaders to abolished the state's enrollment limit that allows only 5,250 Wisconsin students to enroll in virtual classes. The demand for virtual classes exists, Thompson said.
Last year, 1,756 students were placed on a waiting list, but 253 spots were offered within the last nine days of open enrollment, according to the parents' group. Thompson says families had little time to act.
The coalition wants to see the cap lifted in early 2011, before the February open enrollment period begins.

Monday, December 6, 2010

Florida

Using the Digital Learning Council's report on the state of digital learning in America, Wendy Howard, chair of the Florida Chapter of the National Coalition for Public School Options, said Florida has fallen short of three of the report's goals. The state, she added, should move quickly to change its online learning policies.
Florida does not allow students who were not enrolled in a public school the prior year from enrolling in their school district's virtual public school, Howard said. According to the Digital Learning Council's report, "10 Elements of High Quality Digital Learning," students "who are eligible for public school should be eligible for publicly funded digital learning." The report states to "ensure access to high quality digital content and online courses to students in K-12 at any time in their academic career."
Howard also pointed out that Florida law does not permit students to receive an education from an online school program outside of their resident district. The "10 Elements" report, Howard added, addresses such geographic restrictions in the virtual public school context as "illogical," and recommends states "not restrict access to high quality digital content and online course based on geography, such as school district, county, or state."
Finally, Howard said, Florida law does not allow access to multiple high quality online course providers, nor does it allow for other proven digital learning options, such as virtual charter schools – a model in more than 20 states. Parents and students in Florida do not have freedom to choose the online public school or course provider. Children can only attend the online program sponsored by their resident district, and the state does not give families choice or access to multiple course providers through its state-run program.
The Digital Learning Council report urges states to give all students "access to multiple high quality providers … including public, private and nonprofit."
"Here in Florida we have been traditionally viewed as a leader in online education, but there are just too many barriers to access and lack of options for families for that to be true. Sadly, unless changes are made Florida will continue to lag and risks falling further behind many other states," Howard said.
"The time is now for Florida's new leaders to step up, really unleash the potential of digital learning, and give students and families the online education opportunities they demand and deserve," Howard said.

Monday, November 29, 2010

Louisiana

In early December, Louisiana is poised for approval of its first virtual charter schools.
If the November hearing on the proposals is any indication, getting approval is no slam dunk.
There are four virtual charters looking to power up.
Baton Rouge-based Louisiana Connections hopes to win approval for an online charter school that would open in fall 2011 for 500 in grades K-12. Enrollment would be open to students throughout the state.
Also seeking approval is the Louisiana Virtual Academy, which hopes to serve 1,100 students statewide in grades K-12 and the Kaplan Academy of New Orleans, which would initially serve 113 students in grades 6-12.
Finally, also waiting for approval is Provost Academy Louisiana, which is planning for 800 students statewide in grades 9-12.
Louisiana already offers about 5,000 high school students online classes through the Louisiana Virtual School. However, that statewide effort is aimed at providing hard-to-get classes, not as an alternative to traditional schools.
One of the main hurdles to approval of any of the virtual charters is funding.
Last year, public school superintendents in Louisiana complained that online students would get state and local school dollars that would otherwise go to traditional schools. These educators say the state should spend less on students in virtual schools because class size in unlimited and since there is no bricks or mortar to maintain, money for upkeep is unnecessary.
However, at a hearing before the Louisiana Board of Elementary and Secondary Education, Matthew Wick of the International Association for K-12 Online Learning (iNACOL) disagreed. He said that it is a myth that online learning is cheaper than traditional classes. The costs of the technology needed to deliver the courses is a key reason for the cost of online education to be close to the per student cost for teaching students in traditional classrooms.
Another funding issue brought up in Louisiana is the entrance of for-profit companies into the education arena. The question that is repeatedly asked is how can educators prevent virtual schools from turning into financial bonanzas for the companies that provide the curriculum and the teachers?
"That is absolutely a concern," Mark Peevy, executive director of the Georgia Charter Schools Commission told the Baton Rouge Advocate. Georgia is another state wrestling with funding virtual school funding issues.
The Louisiana schools board is set to review the online charter application Dec. 7-9. The expectation is that one or more will be approved.

Monday, November 8, 2010

Florida

What's next for the small class size movement in Florida now that Amendment 8, which would have allowed school officials more flexibility in the number of students allowed in each class, has failed at the polls?
And how will the strict class size regulations impact online classes in Florida? A clue may be what happened at some schools this fall, the first time fines could be imposed on schools that didn't meet class-size rules. Many students were directed to take one or two of their classes through the Florida Virtual School. Florida does not limit the number of students enrolled in an online course.
A little background. In 2002, Florida voters approved a controversial measured that phased in strict class-size limits. The beginning of the 2010-2011 school year was the deadline for all schools to meet the limit. Schools that do not meet the requirements would be fined for every class that is over the limit.
Amendment 8 was placed on the November 2010 ballot to provide wiggle room for the enrollment restrictions. Additionally, The amendment, which would have applied retroactively to the start of the 2010-2011 school year, according to stateline.org.
Backers of Amendment 8 say the legislature can, and should, enact more flexible class-size rules to give schools breathing room without undoing the mandate for fewer kids in each classroom.
That isn't likely to happened. Republican State Sen. Don Gaetz,, who sponsored a version of Amendment 8 in the Florida state Senate told the St. Augustine Record he thinks it would be difficult for the lawmakers to legally make a statutory change "to try to dilute the voters' decision."
He added that he would not be sponsoring another ballot measure on class size. "I believe that the issue is now settled and the losers will be parents and teachers and taxpayers, but that's the constitution," he said.
Some school districts are threatening to sue the state if it issues fines because violations of the limits. These educators say the state has never provided the money necessary to hire additional teachers and help the district meet the class limit goals. If the state doesn't give the schools the
money, and fines the schools for not meeting class-size goals, the schools have no alternative but to sue the state.
Chief Operational Officer Michele LaBute told the Naples Daily News the Collier County School District expects the state Legislature to pay for the implementation of the class-size amendment, but that might not happen. LaBute said the district hasn’t been given the money sufficient to fully implement the class-size amendment for the past three years.
Earlier this year, the Florida Legislature didn’t distribute the estimated $350 million needed to comply with the final provision.
“We expect that the Legislature will give us the funding, as they are required to do by the constitution,” she said.
Another option, of course, is to increase education funding. But the state doesn't have the money. Florida is projected to have a budget shortfall of roughly $2.5 billion in the upcoming fiscal year. A tax increase would bring in additional money, but governor-elect Rick Scott has pledged not to raise taxes.
Finally, there are the courts, where almost everyone involved says the class size issue is likely to land.
What does this mean for virtual education in Florida? A lot. A growing number of school may no longer be able to offer the wide variety of courses, including advanced placement classes.
More and more of the students who want the course most likely will be have encouraged some students to take courses online through the Florida Virtual School.
Already, some Florida educators are calling for mandatory online courses to be added to graduation requirements. If successful, this will again mean growth in online class enrollments.
Nothing is like the change quickly. The Florida Legislature is scheduled to convene on Nov. 16 for new legislators to be sworn in and for a short organizing session. A one-day special session is likely to be held, but education issues are unlikely to be on the agenda.
The regular session of the legislature won't start until spring 2011. That's when class-size issues are likely to be addressed.

Friday, November 5, 2010

Pennsylvania

When the Pennsylvania Legislatures convenes on Nov. 8 for a very short session, one of the top issues discussed will be the state auditor general's call for a moratorium on creation of cyber charter schools.
Basically, Pennsylvania Auditor General Jack Wagner wants to stop charter and cyber charter schools from opening until state officials find a different way of funding all schools.
In October, Wagner issued a 19-page report on what his office perceives to be funding inequities between charter schools and traditional K-12 campuses in Pennsylvania.
In that report, Wagner makes eight recommendations on how to address the differences in state funding of the different schools. The report adds the current formula "has no relationship to the actual cost of charter and cyber charter school education."
Wagner's moratorium call got attention. It is one reason State Rep. James Roebuck Jr. says the Pennsylvania House Education Committee is likely to start discussion on a new funding formula when the new legislative session begins.
"It will be at the top of my agenda," Roebuck told a reporter for the hyper-local website yourplum.com. "We have to look at how we fund and regulate these schools."
Roebuck said the education committee must hold a series of public hearings and get input from several interest groups across the state before drafting legislation. The earliest a piece of legislation could be proposed is during the spring 2011 session.
Nick Trombetta, chief executive officer of PA Cyber, a Midland-based cyber charter school, according to yourplum.com, said he does not support a moratorium or adjusting funding rates for charter and cyber schools. PA Cyber is the largest online school in the state, with an enrollment of more than 10,000 students.
Trombetta told the hyper-local website that education funding is a statewide problem with the entire public school system, and that a flat tuition rate for charter and cyber schools would create a greater inequity.
"If we had a flat rate, some of the wealthier school districts would end up paying less, but the rest would end up paying more," Trombetta said. "Our numbers pay attention to the haves and the have-nots.
"The only way to reform education funding is to find the actual cost of educating a student in Pennsylvania, and mandate that cost in all school districts, " he continued.
"Some school districts spend more, and some spend less," Trombetta said. "That creates huge discrepancies across the board that need addressed."

Tuesday, November 2, 2010

Georgia

One would think that closing a under-performing school with only a few students and replacing it with a hybrid school that features digital and face-to-face instruction with more students, would not be controversial.
One would be wrong.
At the end of the 2009-2010 school year, the Cobb County School District closed Oakwood High School, an alternative school that served 120 students. The reasons were obvious.
Oakwood did not meet Adequate Yearly Progress student achievement goals in 2010 and its graduation rate fell from 56.1 percent in 2009 to 49.8 percent in 2010, according to data supplied by the Georgia Department of Education.
The alternative high school's per-pupil costs were about $18,000 a year, almost three times as much as other high schools in the district. This at a time when the Cobb County district faced a $127 million budget deficit.
The school board did not walk away from Oakwood High, instead it took the opportunity to experiment.
Oakwood High School became Oakwood Digital Academy. The digital school opened its doors for the 2010-2011 school year with 150 students. Another 65 students are on a waiting list. Ombudsman Educational Services, a private company specializing in schools for students with disciplinary problems or those at risk of dropping out of school, came in to run the school. The Cobb school district's contract with Ombudsman allocates $4,950 per student for 180 slots for the 2010-2011 school year.
“The financial strains led to the digital delivery. It was born out of necessity,” Dale Gaddis, a district assistant superintendent told the Atlanta Journal-Constitution.
While school district officials say the quality of education at the digital academy is high, some parents and students are still unconvinced. Some students of the former Oakwood High School have left. Others, however, stayed at the new digital academy.
"I had to come here. I couldn't go back to traditional school. I like working on the computers. It’s easier than having to sit all day and listen to a teacher,” James Mack, 18, told the Journal-Constitution.

Tuesday, October 19, 2010

Florida

Can Florida's fast-growing online class enrollment survive Amendment 8, a ballot measure that will determine the future of K-12 class size, on the November 2010 Florida ballot?

Florida voters were clear in 2002--they wanted to limit the size of public school classes. No more than 18 students in pre-kindergarten through third grade, 22 in fourth through eighth grade and 25 in high school.

This directive was phased in and finally fully implemented at the beginning 2010 school year. That's when the impact was felt. Principals scrambled to make to meet the mandate. They had to--for every student over the maximum, the school would have to pay a fine of $3,000 per
student.

However, there was one seemingly unintended benefit of the class size vote: online classes grew rapidly. From Miami to Tallahassee, from Tampa Bay, to Melbourne, schools channeled more and more students to online courses. The reason: There is no limit on the number of students in online classes.

The students jumped at the opportunity to take some of their classes online.

Andrew Helms, a Florida high school junior, expressed his enthusiasm at the offer of taking World History online when his school had no classroom seats
available for him.

"It's like college at home," Andrew told Tampbay.com. He plans to take the course in the evenings and use his open class period to complete other school assignments.

"I like working on computers."

Basically, Amendment 8 asks voters to change the current class size maximums to
"school-wide average" class size. According to the proponents, this change would bring about "flexibility" for schools.

Amendment 8 opponents say the current battle is really about funding because it's expected to save $350 million to $1 billion in class-size costs every year. The opponents say since Amendment 8 does not guarantee that the savings will go back to schools, the proposed law is a way to stop fully funding public schools and increase class size.

If Florida voters decided to stick with the current class size rules, enrollment in online classes is sure to grow, and grow fast.

If voters decide "flexibility" is better, enrollment in online course may grow, but not as fast.

Monday, October 11, 2010

Pennsylvania

Pennsylvania Auditor General Jack Wagner fired the first volley. He called for a moratorium on creation of cyber-charter and charter schools until a new state funding system is in place. According to Wagner, the current funding system has serious inequities in how tax money is used to finance these public school alternatives.
Reaction was swift.Newspaper editorial took competing sides of the issue. The York Dispatch praised Wagner's stand. The moratorium is the right thing to do, the editorial board wrote, because overhauling the funding system is "long overdue.
On the other side, the Pittsburgh Tribune said Wagner's idea of a moratorium was "charter school claptrap."
"There would be no "issue" over districts' tuition payments if the alternative to public education's status quo wasn't in fact nibbling away at the edutocracy's lunch," wrote the editorial board.
Leading Pennsylvania educators were quick to defend--and denounce--Wagner's proposal.
Ron Sofo — superintendent of Freedom Area School District — said “in tough economic times — when everybody’s scraping to get by — you have to find a system that’s more fiscally responsible to everyone.”
Nick Trombetta — chief executive officer at the Midland-based Pennsylvania Cyber Charter School — said the present system “expects us to do as much (as a public school) with less (money per student) — and we’ve been doing a reasonably good job with it at PA Cyber — so I don’t see where we’re the problem.”

Monday, September 27, 2010

Maryland

The governor allowed a bill authorizing creation of virtual public schools to become law without his signature because he says he doesn't know how the state will fund these schools.
Angry parents groups launched a campaign to push state legislators to develop a plan to help finance virtual schools in Maryland. The parents also complained about other hurdles place in front of the virtual education movement in Maryland. Their complaints include that:


  • Maryland does not have a virtual charter school that offers courses to students throughout the state.

  • State law prevents the creation of cyber charter schools.

  • Only a handful of Maryland schools offer any sort of hybrid or blended learning opportunities.

According to the Center for Digital Education, Maryland ranks 24th among the 50 states in offering online learning opportunities.This all lays the groundwork for a showdown between virtual education activists and state officials.


In early September, the Maryland Public Policy Institute held a symposium called How Maryland Can Become a Leader in K-12 Online.


Later in the month, Dan Lips, a Senior Fellow of Education Policy Studies at the institute, issued his report on the subject.


In October, Emerging Minds of Maryland, a nonprofit group pushing for expansion of online learning in Maryland, is scheduling workshops to talk about educational options throughout the state and what can be done to increase the availability of online choices for K-12 students.


"As online learning sweeps the nation and transforms American education, Marylanders should ask why their children can't benefit from the most innovative learning models. They should demand that policymakers in Annapolis make the state a leader in the online learning revolution," Lips wrote in an op-ed published in the Baltimore Sun. "How much longer will we wait to bring students back to the future?"

Wednesday, September 15, 2010

Wisconsin

Textbook grassroots activism. That's what has been happening in Wisconsin over the past few months.
An enrollment cap on enrollment in virtual schools left hundreds of students on waiting lists. Parents said keeping their children in school limbo was wrong and putting their children at an educational disadvantage.
The controversy over wait list was the law is not the first time Wisconsin has been in the the cross hairs of the virtual education movement.
Online learning in Wisconsin gained national attention when an appeals court ruled in December 2007 that the Wisconsin Virtual Academy (WIVA), a charter school established by the Northern Ozaukee School District and affiliated with K12 Inc., violated state laws and was not eligible for state funding, according to the 2009 edition of "Keeping Pace with K-12 Online Learning."
To prevent online charter schools in Wisconsin from being denied funding and force to close, the Wisconsin legislature approved the Virtual School Rescue Act, also known as Act 222. This law made changes to charter schools, open enrollment, and teacher licensing laws. These changes allowed the virtual charter schools to get public money.
Act 222 also put a 5,250-student cap on statewide virtual school enrollment. By the summer of 2010, more than 1,700 students were on the virtual school enrollment waiting list.
That's when virtual school parents groups went into action.
The Wisconsin Coalition of Virtual School Families started an online petition drive to lift the cap and find ways to enroll all of the children into virtual schools.
By late August, just a few days before the start of the school year, the Wisconsin Department of Public Instruction announced there were no more students on the waiting list.
But Julie Thompson of the Wisconsin Coalition of Virtual School Families said it wasn't as if everyone who signed on is getting into their chosen school.
She said more than 1,700 families were on the list before summer, but that number had dwindled to roughly 250 by the time Wisconsin school officials announced that there were no more students on the waiting list.
The parents, Thompson said, "Decided, `Well, this is too stressful to wait, I don’t like not knowing, I need to make my plans for the fall,’ so a lot of them dropped out. "

Wednesday, September 8, 2010

Texas

It's Houston's virtual school vs. the Texas Education Agency. In the middle of this shootout: about 1,600 students whose online school has lost its accreditation.

Two days before school opend, the Houston Independent School District was told that its online education partner, Texas Connections Academy Houston, would not get an "appropriate" rating. That ruling meant the program's expansion, which added 1,600 new students to the already 1,000-student enrollment, was denied.

The problem, according to the state education agency, test scores. Lower than anticipated scores on the math portion of the Texas Assessment of Knowlege and Skills (TAKS) exam.

According to an education agency statement, "The expansion was denied because the students in this program had a passing rate that was 20 percent below the statewide passing rate on the TAKS test. The program remains accredited for the current students."

Houston school officials have appealed the ruling, says ancy Manley, the district's compliance officer.

In the meantime, the new online students have been left in the lurch.

“We’d like to stay with HISD,” said Pam Kehoe, whose 13-year-old son is being home-schooled in partnership with the virtual school program. “It’s the only reason we came back to public school.”

Monday, August 30, 2010

Illinois

There are benefits to a longer school day. Research is mounting that to support this view. For instance, a 2010 report released by Mathematica Policy Research, found that the extended time at Knowledge is Power Program (KIPP) schools helped KIPP students out perform their peers attending traditional public schools.

So when it was announced that 15 Chicago schools would add 90 minutes to the school day, and that students would be using online learning resources monitored by non-teachers, you would think this experiment would be welcomed.

You would be wrong.

The Chicago Teachers Union called the plan "education on the cheap" and said the federal stimulus money that is expected to cover most of the experiment's cost would go to pay "baby-sitters."

Chicago has one of the shortest school days in the nation. Three years ago, efforts to negotiate longer school days failed.

"All of our efforts to expand the school day with the traditional work force were, unfortunately, rejected," Ron Huberman, Chicago Public Schools chief said in support of experiment

The Chicago school system is the epicenter of online experimentation in Illinois. Supporters say all they need is a little time and flexibility to show virtual classes can help children learn

"A computer never replaces a teacher," Huberman added. But "it allows the most talented and gifted students to move extra fast and the students struggling to take the time they need to before moving on to the next task."

Tuesday, August 24, 2010

Oregon

The ongoing struggle between Oregon's education establishment and the virtual education movement has not let up.

Oregon's first virtual charter school opened in 2005. Almost immediately, some educators, unions, and politicians expressed fears that the virtual schools would draw students and resources away from traditional campuses.

According to Oregon education rules, state money follows students to whatever public school they attend.

About 1 percent of Oregon's nearly 600,000 students attend online schools.

Meanwhile parents and virtual education activists say the state is doing everything it can to discourage participation in online learning.

In May 2010, parents of students attending Oregon Virtual Academy told policymakers that their local school districts were making it difficult for them to transfer their children to the virtual school.

In August, Oregon Board of Education members said they would support a cap on the number of students who leave traditional public schools for charters or virtual charter schools.

Add to this ongoing battle new restrictive laws that make operating virtual schools in Oregon more and more difficult, and it is little wonder that Liberating Learning Blog contributor Christina Martin asks if the state's virtual charter schools will survive.

Friday, August 20, 2010

Georgia

After a tumultuous week in the corridors of power, the scoreboard for the Georgia virtual education movement reads: 2 wins, 1 setback.

Early in the week, the Georgia Board of Education upheld a lower commission's denial of an application to create the Georgia Virtual Academy Charter School.

A couple of days later, the state Board of Education approved adding a ninth grade to the Georgia Cyber Academy. About 600 students were awaiting the decision in order to enroll in the online school.

At the end of the week, the Georgia Charter Schools Commission said it would review its decision to fund two recently approved charter schools with only a fraction of the money students attending traditional schools receive. According to the Atlanta Journal-Constitution, commissioners "admitted they may have low-balled the cost of virtual public education."

The commission's action came after the Georgia Families for Virtual Public Education put up a vocal and public fight to get the commission to change its funding policy. Click here to see a strongly worded letter to the commission outlining the parents' position.

Tuesday, August 17, 2010

Oklahoma

A virtual school district. That's what an Oklahoma judge may have created when she ruled that state's Department of Education should fund a K-12 virtual charter school that can enroll students from throughout the state.
The ruling, however, may have come too late for Epic 1 on 1 Charter School to open its doors this fall as planned.
The judge's ruling left Oklahoma School Superintendent Sandy Garrett "perplexed" at why the judge took this route."We don't have a school district that has no representation through their community through a democratic election."
Oklahoma has other virtual schools, but they are offered through existing school districts.
The ruling momentarily ended a bruising fight that pitted Epic against the state's education department and the University of Central Oklahoma, which Epic founders say is its sponsoring agency. The university says it does not have an approved contract with Epic.

Monday, August 9, 2010

Georgia

The showdown is set for Aug. 19. On one side, the Georgia Families for Public Virtual Education; on the other, the state's Charter School Commission. The issue: funding for two virtual charter schools that would offer courses to high school students throughout the state.
Earlier this year, the Charter School Commission gave its approval for the creation of the state's first virtual charter high schools. At the same time, the commission decided not to fund the virtual high schools at the same level it funds bricks-and-mortar high schools. The charter schools were allocated about $3,200 per pupil. That is well under the $8,800 per student the state provides Georgia students attending traditional high schools.
Kaplan Academy of Georgia and Provost Academy Georgia, the contractors approved to run the schools, said they could not provide students with a quality education for $3,500 per student. Both tabled their deals with the state.
In a letter to the commission, the Georgia Families for Public Virtual Education urged the commission to reconsider the funding allocation. The parents' group said it was bringing its lawyer to the Aug. 19 meeting and hoped to meet with board members about the issue.

Tuesday, August 3, 2010

Massachusetts

The plan seemed so direct. Massachusetts would open its first state-led virtual school in the fall of 2010.
Turning this vision into reality has not been easy.
In May, state approval was given to open the Massachusetts Virtual Academy, a K-8 school that would be based in Greenfield, a town in the western portion of the state. The goal was that students from throughout the state would be able to enroll in the Massachusetts Virtual Academy.
That goal may not come true.
In July, over protests, the Massachusetts Board of Elementary and Secondary Education placed several restrictions on virtual schools. The board capped enrollment in virtual schools at 500. What's more 25 percent of the 500 must be students who live in the district where the virtual school is based.
The Greenfield plan called for enrollment of only a handful of students from the local district.
Greenfield officials hope to get a waiver so they can still open this fall with a statewide. enrollment.
State officials have not indicated if a decision on a wavier will be given before the start of the school year.