And so it begins again. Debate over cyber charter and traditional charter schools in Pennsylvania has returned to the spotlight.
Returning to center stage are two bills, SB 904 and HB 1348. The companion bills would streamline legal procedures to launch a charter school, lift all enrollment caps and creates an appeal procedure if a local school board rejects a viable charter school application.
Earlier this year, Pennsylvania Auditor General Jack Wagner called for a moratorium on the creation of new cyber charter and charter schools until a new funding system can be put into place.
School districts in Pennsylvania agreed with Wagner. Pennsylvania has 159 charter schools and 13 cyber charter schools with more than
90,000 students enrolled. They receive funding from local public school districts. The districts say current funding system, which for cyber charter students, called for them to send district-generate funds as well as state money to online course providers. This is one reason this year school districts from the Poconos to State College, Penn., have launched their own virtual schools. These districts want to keep their students, and the money, in the local district.
Opponents of the measures say the bills will reduce accountability for charter schools.
In a blog post, The Education Law Center of Pennsylvania, a legal advocacy group, said it "believes that important reforms are needed for Pennsylvania’s system of charter and cyber charter schools. Unfortunately, Senate Bill 904 and similar legislation introduced in
the House of Representatives do not include the reforms truly needed to strengthen the charter school system. Instead, these bills include changes that would greatly expand the number and size of charter schools, would replace the role of local school districts in
approving and monitoring charter schools with a new state agency in Harrisburg, and would water down the accountability system for charter schools. This is the wrong approach," according to the law center.
After he testified before a legislative committee, the executive director of the Pennsylvania School Board Association made a video in which he remained non-committal about the legislation, but added he wished it contained funding reform.
Proponents, however, see the legislation as long over due and very much needed.
"It is clear to me that we are at a pivotal time in Pennsylvania’s education reform movement. The early success of charter schools can either be a firm foundation upon which a new child centered system of public education will be built, or another attempt at reform that
was bastardized and destroyed by our inability to break away from the status quo," Lawrence Jones, president of the Pennsylvania Coalition for Public Charter Schools, told a Pennsylvania education legislative committee.
Tuesday, August 30, 2011
Tuesday, August 9, 2011
Michigan
New rules issued by the Michigan Department of Education will expand online learning opportunities for students throughout the state.
Everyone isn't happy.
Before the new regulations were issued, Michigan law limited students to two online classes a semester. School district and virtual charter school that allowed students to take more than two online classes operated under special waivers from the Michigan Department
of Education.
The new rules, issued in July, make it easier for school districts to get waivers to the state law. This means, for example, the state's 57 middle school districts can create virtual charter schools for up to 10% of students who reside in the district's boundaries. What's more, middle school students would be able to take all or most of their classes online. Prior to the rule change,
these student could only take two courses per semester.
The education department also issued new rules that streamline the process for approval of seat-time waivers.
The impact of the new rules was felt quickly. The Michigan Department of Education reported it has received a half-dozen applications from districts since the guidelines were issued last month. More applications are in the pipeline, state officials said.
The new guidelines are in response to Gov. Rick Snyder's push for the Legislature to remove rules that cap some online enrollment.
Although the MDE has the power to give districts flexibility, the Legislature would need to act to completely remove restrictions. "We
agree with the governor that this is a good thing for students," Barbara Fardell, a manager in the state Office of Educational Improvement and Innovation, told the Detroit News.
Proponents of the new rules allowing for the expansion of online learning opportunities are heartened by the moves of the education department.
"We want educators to have the flexibility to reach every student as we reinvent our education system that will allow students to learn any time, any place, any way, and at any pace," said State Superintendent of Schools Mike Flanagan.
Michael Van Beek, director of education policy at the Mackinac Center for Public Policy, added that it is time that Michigan should be like other states that have more open access to online education.
Opponents of the rule change urged state education officials move slower and add safeguards to any growth of online learning.
The Michigan Education Association, the state's largest teacher's union, provided guidance to its members on virtual education issues.
In a 2009, union-endorsed report called "The Realities of K-12 Virtual Education," the authors wrote, " the rapid growth of this new form of schooling raises questions of cost, funding, and variable quality that require the immediate attention of policymakers."
The report recommends that before policy changes that allow for more online learning options, policy makers:
-- Adopt new regulations governing the provision of online K-12 schooling.
-- Call for audits of providers of virtual education.
-- Recognize legitimate accrediting agencies.
-- Require credible assessment and evaluation.
Everyone isn't happy.
Before the new regulations were issued, Michigan law limited students to two online classes a semester. School district and virtual charter school that allowed students to take more than two online classes operated under special waivers from the Michigan Department
of Education.
The new rules, issued in July, make it easier for school districts to get waivers to the state law. This means, for example, the state's 57 middle school districts can create virtual charter schools for up to 10% of students who reside in the district's boundaries. What's more, middle school students would be able to take all or most of their classes online. Prior to the rule change,
these student could only take two courses per semester.
The education department also issued new rules that streamline the process for approval of seat-time waivers.
The impact of the new rules was felt quickly. The Michigan Department of Education reported it has received a half-dozen applications from districts since the guidelines were issued last month. More applications are in the pipeline, state officials said.
The new guidelines are in response to Gov. Rick Snyder's push for the Legislature to remove rules that cap some online enrollment.
Although the MDE has the power to give districts flexibility, the Legislature would need to act to completely remove restrictions. "We
agree with the governor that this is a good thing for students," Barbara Fardell, a manager in the state Office of Educational Improvement and Innovation, told the Detroit News.
Proponents of the new rules allowing for the expansion of online learning opportunities are heartened by the moves of the education department.
"We want educators to have the flexibility to reach every student as we reinvent our education system that will allow students to learn any time, any place, any way, and at any pace," said State Superintendent of Schools Mike Flanagan.
Michael Van Beek, director of education policy at the Mackinac Center for Public Policy, added that it is time that Michigan should be like other states that have more open access to online education.
Opponents of the rule change urged state education officials move slower and add safeguards to any growth of online learning.
The Michigan Education Association, the state's largest teacher's union, provided guidance to its members on virtual education issues.
In a 2009, union-endorsed report called "The Realities of K-12 Virtual Education," the authors wrote, " the rapid growth of this new form of schooling raises questions of cost, funding, and variable quality that require the immediate attention of policymakers."
The report recommends that before policy changes that allow for more online learning options, policy makers:
-- Adopt new regulations governing the provision of online K-12 schooling.
-- Call for audits of providers of virtual education.
-- Recognize legitimate accrediting agencies.
-- Require credible assessment and evaluation.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)