Monday, November 29, 2010

Louisiana

In early December, Louisiana is poised for approval of its first virtual charter schools.
If the November hearing on the proposals is any indication, getting approval is no slam dunk.
There are four virtual charters looking to power up.
Baton Rouge-based Louisiana Connections hopes to win approval for an online charter school that would open in fall 2011 for 500 in grades K-12. Enrollment would be open to students throughout the state.
Also seeking approval is the Louisiana Virtual Academy, which hopes to serve 1,100 students statewide in grades K-12 and the Kaplan Academy of New Orleans, which would initially serve 113 students in grades 6-12.
Finally, also waiting for approval is Provost Academy Louisiana, which is planning for 800 students statewide in grades 9-12.
Louisiana already offers about 5,000 high school students online classes through the Louisiana Virtual School. However, that statewide effort is aimed at providing hard-to-get classes, not as an alternative to traditional schools.
One of the main hurdles to approval of any of the virtual charters is funding.
Last year, public school superintendents in Louisiana complained that online students would get state and local school dollars that would otherwise go to traditional schools. These educators say the state should spend less on students in virtual schools because class size in unlimited and since there is no bricks or mortar to maintain, money for upkeep is unnecessary.
However, at a hearing before the Louisiana Board of Elementary and Secondary Education, Matthew Wick of the International Association for K-12 Online Learning (iNACOL) disagreed. He said that it is a myth that online learning is cheaper than traditional classes. The costs of the technology needed to deliver the courses is a key reason for the cost of online education to be close to the per student cost for teaching students in traditional classrooms.
Another funding issue brought up in Louisiana is the entrance of for-profit companies into the education arena. The question that is repeatedly asked is how can educators prevent virtual schools from turning into financial bonanzas for the companies that provide the curriculum and the teachers?
"That is absolutely a concern," Mark Peevy, executive director of the Georgia Charter Schools Commission told the Baton Rouge Advocate. Georgia is another state wrestling with funding virtual school funding issues.
The Louisiana schools board is set to review the online charter application Dec. 7-9. The expectation is that one or more will be approved.

Monday, November 8, 2010

Florida

What's next for the small class size movement in Florida now that Amendment 8, which would have allowed school officials more flexibility in the number of students allowed in each class, has failed at the polls?
And how will the strict class size regulations impact online classes in Florida? A clue may be what happened at some schools this fall, the first time fines could be imposed on schools that didn't meet class-size rules. Many students were directed to take one or two of their classes through the Florida Virtual School. Florida does not limit the number of students enrolled in an online course.
A little background. In 2002, Florida voters approved a controversial measured that phased in strict class-size limits. The beginning of the 2010-2011 school year was the deadline for all schools to meet the limit. Schools that do not meet the requirements would be fined for every class that is over the limit.
Amendment 8 was placed on the November 2010 ballot to provide wiggle room for the enrollment restrictions. Additionally, The amendment, which would have applied retroactively to the start of the 2010-2011 school year, according to stateline.org.
Backers of Amendment 8 say the legislature can, and should, enact more flexible class-size rules to give schools breathing room without undoing the mandate for fewer kids in each classroom.
That isn't likely to happened. Republican State Sen. Don Gaetz,, who sponsored a version of Amendment 8 in the Florida state Senate told the St. Augustine Record he thinks it would be difficult for the lawmakers to legally make a statutory change "to try to dilute the voters' decision."
He added that he would not be sponsoring another ballot measure on class size. "I believe that the issue is now settled and the losers will be parents and teachers and taxpayers, but that's the constitution," he said.
Some school districts are threatening to sue the state if it issues fines because violations of the limits. These educators say the state has never provided the money necessary to hire additional teachers and help the district meet the class limit goals. If the state doesn't give the schools the
money, and fines the schools for not meeting class-size goals, the schools have no alternative but to sue the state.
Chief Operational Officer Michele LaBute told the Naples Daily News the Collier County School District expects the state Legislature to pay for the implementation of the class-size amendment, but that might not happen. LaBute said the district hasn’t been given the money sufficient to fully implement the class-size amendment for the past three years.
Earlier this year, the Florida Legislature didn’t distribute the estimated $350 million needed to comply with the final provision.
“We expect that the Legislature will give us the funding, as they are required to do by the constitution,” she said.
Another option, of course, is to increase education funding. But the state doesn't have the money. Florida is projected to have a budget shortfall of roughly $2.5 billion in the upcoming fiscal year. A tax increase would bring in additional money, but governor-elect Rick Scott has pledged not to raise taxes.
Finally, there are the courts, where almost everyone involved says the class size issue is likely to land.
What does this mean for virtual education in Florida? A lot. A growing number of school may no longer be able to offer the wide variety of courses, including advanced placement classes.
More and more of the students who want the course most likely will be have encouraged some students to take courses online through the Florida Virtual School.
Already, some Florida educators are calling for mandatory online courses to be added to graduation requirements. If successful, this will again mean growth in online class enrollments.
Nothing is like the change quickly. The Florida Legislature is scheduled to convene on Nov. 16 for new legislators to be sworn in and for a short organizing session. A one-day special session is likely to be held, but education issues are unlikely to be on the agenda.
The regular session of the legislature won't start until spring 2011. That's when class-size issues are likely to be addressed.

Friday, November 5, 2010

Pennsylvania

When the Pennsylvania Legislatures convenes on Nov. 8 for a very short session, one of the top issues discussed will be the state auditor general's call for a moratorium on creation of cyber charter schools.
Basically, Pennsylvania Auditor General Jack Wagner wants to stop charter and cyber charter schools from opening until state officials find a different way of funding all schools.
In October, Wagner issued a 19-page report on what his office perceives to be funding inequities between charter schools and traditional K-12 campuses in Pennsylvania.
In that report, Wagner makes eight recommendations on how to address the differences in state funding of the different schools. The report adds the current formula "has no relationship to the actual cost of charter and cyber charter school education."
Wagner's moratorium call got attention. It is one reason State Rep. James Roebuck Jr. says the Pennsylvania House Education Committee is likely to start discussion on a new funding formula when the new legislative session begins.
"It will be at the top of my agenda," Roebuck told a reporter for the hyper-local website yourplum.com. "We have to look at how we fund and regulate these schools."
Roebuck said the education committee must hold a series of public hearings and get input from several interest groups across the state before drafting legislation. The earliest a piece of legislation could be proposed is during the spring 2011 session.
Nick Trombetta, chief executive officer of PA Cyber, a Midland-based cyber charter school, according to yourplum.com, said he does not support a moratorium or adjusting funding rates for charter and cyber schools. PA Cyber is the largest online school in the state, with an enrollment of more than 10,000 students.
Trombetta told the hyper-local website that education funding is a statewide problem with the entire public school system, and that a flat tuition rate for charter and cyber schools would create a greater inequity.
"If we had a flat rate, some of the wealthier school districts would end up paying less, but the rest would end up paying more," Trombetta said. "Our numbers pay attention to the haves and the have-nots.
"The only way to reform education funding is to find the actual cost of educating a student in Pennsylvania, and mandate that cost in all school districts, " he continued.
"Some school districts spend more, and some spend less," Trombetta said. "That creates huge discrepancies across the board that need addressed."

Tuesday, November 2, 2010

Georgia

One would think that closing a under-performing school with only a few students and replacing it with a hybrid school that features digital and face-to-face instruction with more students, would not be controversial.
One would be wrong.
At the end of the 2009-2010 school year, the Cobb County School District closed Oakwood High School, an alternative school that served 120 students. The reasons were obvious.
Oakwood did not meet Adequate Yearly Progress student achievement goals in 2010 and its graduation rate fell from 56.1 percent in 2009 to 49.8 percent in 2010, according to data supplied by the Georgia Department of Education.
The alternative high school's per-pupil costs were about $18,000 a year, almost three times as much as other high schools in the district. This at a time when the Cobb County district faced a $127 million budget deficit.
The school board did not walk away from Oakwood High, instead it took the opportunity to experiment.
Oakwood High School became Oakwood Digital Academy. The digital school opened its doors for the 2010-2011 school year with 150 students. Another 65 students are on a waiting list. Ombudsman Educational Services, a private company specializing in schools for students with disciplinary problems or those at risk of dropping out of school, came in to run the school. The Cobb school district's contract with Ombudsman allocates $4,950 per student for 180 slots for the 2010-2011 school year.
“The financial strains led to the digital delivery. It was born out of necessity,” Dale Gaddis, a district assistant superintendent told the Atlanta Journal-Constitution.
While school district officials say the quality of education at the digital academy is high, some parents and students are still unconvinced. Some students of the former Oakwood High School have left. Others, however, stayed at the new digital academy.
"I had to come here. I couldn't go back to traditional school. I like working on the computers. It’s easier than having to sit all day and listen to a teacher,” James Mack, 18, told the Journal-Constitution.