The Arizona legislature is turning its attention to the state's booming K-12 online learning environment.
And, it seems, no matter what side of the online learning debate you are on, clarifying funding and increasing accountability is a good direction to take.
Of course, the devil is in the details.
There are several bills currently winding their way through the legislature. Senate Bill 1259 would allow online providers to earn more state funding if students finish courses and demonstrate, on state-approved tests, that they have mastered the content. The measure would also create a separate funding option from that of the current Arizona Online Instruction Program.
House Bill 2260 could make it easier for district-school students to take more online courses from the district or an outside school. One provision in the bill would require districts to accept credits from all other state-approved online courses.
A third bill, SB 1463, would require online schools to supervise final exams, which some educators believe would help deter cheating. Currently, Arizona requires only that statewide assessments, such as the Arizona's Instrument to Measure Standards test, be given in person.
Some say a 2011 Arizona Republic investigative series on online education for the legislative attention. The series claimed that Arizona's online K-12 programs have relatively lax oversight and limited disclosure of information and argued that there were few or no requirements for how schools monitor their tests. The risks, the series charged, of cheating in the largest online schools were high.
Despite such problems and a critical state audit in 2007, according to the Republic's reporting, the state Legislature in 2009 removed caps on the number of online schools allowed to operate.
Since removal of the enrollment cap, the number of district and charter online schools has jumped from 14 to 66 schools. Nearly 36,000 students took one or more online classes in the 2010-11 school year.
Even if the legislation is a product of its series, the Republic reports, it is unclear which of the bills, if any, will become law.
Proponents of the measures, such as Jonathan Butcher, education director at the Arizona-based Goldwater Institute, say much of the legislation is the “type of leg-up the virtual world needs to be the most effective."
Butcher added that said he supports innovative practices that provide a la carte education, and that online schools help increase school choice by creating innovative avenues for students to utilize several different school options simultaneously.
Opponents to the measures, and to SB 1259 particularly, criticized it as too soft, saying it appeared to have "symbolic" accountability provisions added to help get it through the legislature. Some online learning backers say in-person supervision of students taking statewide exams online will be burdensome to students who live in rural areas.
The Arizona School Boards Association hasn't taken a position on the bills, but its lobbyist, Janice Palmer, told the Arizona Republic that the group supports bringing more accountability to online courses and making sure students are learning.
Liberating Learning Battleground
Tuesday, March 13, 2012
Monday, March 5, 2012
Virginia
Two of Liberating Learning's Blog contributors, Tom Vander Ark and Michael B. Horn, have come out swinging against a Virginia bill both say will hurt the online learning movement in that state.
SB 598, as amended, would limit a family's education choice to the alternatives their local district offers. If the local district doesn't offer a virtual education program, parents could not choose that option for their kids.
"The whole point of learning online to is to provide every Virginia student great options and flexibility in rate, time, and location" Vander Ark wrote.
"In essence, as the bill is now written, districts would have veto power over students’ ability to enroll—or stay enrolled—in an online program that meets their needs if the program is housed outside of the district." Horn wrote.
Click here for Vander Ark's complete post.
Click here for all of Horn's essay.
SB 598, as amended, would limit a family's education choice to the alternatives their local district offers. If the local district doesn't offer a virtual education program, parents could not choose that option for their kids.
"The whole point of learning online to is to provide every Virginia student great options and flexibility in rate, time, and location" Vander Ark wrote.
"In essence, as the bill is now written, districts would have veto power over students’ ability to enroll—or stay enrolled—in an online program that meets their needs if the program is housed outside of the district." Horn wrote.
Click here for Vander Ark's complete post.
Click here for all of Horn's essay.
Thursday, February 23, 2012
Mississippi
All it took to removed virtual education from Mississippi charter school legislation was a voice vote.
There appeared to be widespread support for strengthening the state's charter school law through Senate Bill 2401. In fact, the state full state Senate would later approve the bill. The Mississippi may vote on it by the beginning of March.
But it was a different matter for including virtual charter schools in the measure. Advocates of virtual charter schools didn't even get the satisfaction of finding out which legislators were on their side and which legislators were against virtual charters.
A voice vote to turn back virtual charter schools was all that was needed.
"This is the first step in the process," said Sen. David Blount, who offered the amendment to remove the virtual charter school component. He told the Northeast Mississippi Daily Journal that studies have shown in other states that the virtual charter schools have not been successful.
Senate Education Chair Gray Tollison disagreed. He argued that because of ever-changing technology language to allow online schools was needed in the bill.
Several stumbling blocks appear to have gotten in the way of inclusion of virtual charter schools in SB 2401.
Derrick Johnson, president of the Mississippi State Conference NAACP, told the Daily Mississippian the he believed virtual charter schools would take money from traditional public schools and send it to companies outside of the state. He also said they would be detrimental to the state economically and that the performance of virtual charter schools is worse than any other form of education in the country.
“Quality education should come before corporate profit,” Johnson said.
Mike Sayer, senior organizer and training coordinator for Southern Echo, a community development group that works in rural African-American communities, thinks charter schools would fail to provide a quality education to students.
“The record of virtual charter school is horrendous in terms of under-performing traditional public schools,” he said.
Southern Echo and the Mississippi NAACP chapter have also voiced concerns over expansion of brick-and-mortar charter schools.
But Rachel Canter, executive director of Mississippi First, a group that supports the charter school legislation, disagreed.
“I think that digital learning and virtual learning are here to stay,” she said. “The question is, ‘Is there a way to put in the bill to make sure that virtual school providers have to meet rigorous standards and that they are held accountable for the education they provide?’ An outright prohibition on virtual schools, I think, is probably not the best way to go about it.”
There appeared to be widespread support for strengthening the state's charter school law through Senate Bill 2401. In fact, the state full state Senate would later approve the bill. The Mississippi may vote on it by the beginning of March.
But it was a different matter for including virtual charter schools in the measure. Advocates of virtual charter schools didn't even get the satisfaction of finding out which legislators were on their side and which legislators were against virtual charters.
A voice vote to turn back virtual charter schools was all that was needed.
"This is the first step in the process," said Sen. David Blount, who offered the amendment to remove the virtual charter school component. He told the Northeast Mississippi Daily Journal that studies have shown in other states that the virtual charter schools have not been successful.
Senate Education Chair Gray Tollison disagreed. He argued that because of ever-changing technology language to allow online schools was needed in the bill.
Several stumbling blocks appear to have gotten in the way of inclusion of virtual charter schools in SB 2401.
Derrick Johnson, president of the Mississippi State Conference NAACP, told the Daily Mississippian the he believed virtual charter schools would take money from traditional public schools and send it to companies outside of the state. He also said they would be detrimental to the state economically and that the performance of virtual charter schools is worse than any other form of education in the country.
“Quality education should come before corporate profit,” Johnson said.
Mike Sayer, senior organizer and training coordinator for Southern Echo, a community development group that works in rural African-American communities, thinks charter schools would fail to provide a quality education to students.
“The record of virtual charter school is horrendous in terms of under-performing traditional public schools,” he said.
Southern Echo and the Mississippi NAACP chapter have also voiced concerns over expansion of brick-and-mortar charter schools.
But Rachel Canter, executive director of Mississippi First, a group that supports the charter school legislation, disagreed.
“I think that digital learning and virtual learning are here to stay,” she said. “The question is, ‘Is there a way to put in the bill to make sure that virtual school providers have to meet rigorous standards and that they are held accountable for the education they provide?’ An outright prohibition on virtual schools, I think, is probably not the best way to go about it.”
Monday, February 13, 2012
Virginia
Gov. Bob McDonnell wants to change the way Virginia channels state education money to students attending virtual schools.
Under the proposed legislation, students who enroll in virtual school programs would be funded based on where they live, not where they enroll. The per pupil amount of local and state funds would be capped at $6,500.
The virtual education funding proposal is part of an omnibus education reform plan championed by the McDonnell. The package includes overhauling the public school teacher contracts, tenure and the evaluation process.
One of the measures in the reform package, HB 1173, would mandate that 90 percent of per-pupil funding follow a student to a public charter school
"It's been a bleak week for public education," said Robley Jones of the Virginia Education Association. Much attention, he said, is being paid to virtual and charter schools when public schools educate the vast majority of the state's children.
That said, the VEA does agree that a new mechanism is needed to fund virtual education in Virginia.
"It only seems logical that a virtual school would not require student transportation, food services, custodial, and other costs related to the cost of a bricks and mortar education," according to the VEA statement. "Virginia currently spends state dollars to fund the Virginia Virtual Academy at about the same per-pupil cost as a bricks and mortar school. The true cost of a virtual school education should determine the level of funding, not the ADM (Average Daily Membership) amount currently in use."
Wednesday, February 8, 2012
Michigan
At long last, Michigan's House Education Committee approved SB 619, which will lift the cyber charter enrollment cap.
The approved bill does have some restriction. But after months of wrangling, it is head for a full House vote.
Michigan's state Senate has already approved SB 619.
Under the revised legislation approved by the House committee, the number of cyber charters schools in Michigan would be capped 15 until 2013. After that, the bill would allow the number to increase to 30.
The bill also states that school districts, which also offer cyber programs, cannot authorize more than one of the programs.
The version that passed the state Senate had no restrictions on the number of schools.
The House bill also caps the number of students enrolled in cyber charters statewide to half the number of students attending Michigan’s largest district. State law now limits enrollment to 400 students.
Opponents of the measure said cyber charters in Michigan are expanding too quickly. They asked for more time to review the two cyber charters schools that opened in fall 2010.
Proponents argued Proponents of SB 619 believe it offers more options to students, as well as ties in strong use of technology.
"This is a case of the education establishment in this state not wanting parents to have choices,” Education Committee chairman Thomas McMillin told MLive.com. “They want to be in control.”
Friday, February 3, 2012
Michigan
This may be showdown week for Michigan's SB 619, the bill that would lift the enrollment cap on virtual charter schools in the state.
After months of delay and weeks of hearings, Feb. 8 is the target for the Michigan House Education Committee to take a vote. If the measure makes it out of committee, it will go to the full house for a vote. The Michigan state Senate has already approved the legislation.
Currently, there are two cyber schools in Michigan with an enrollment of 400 students each. Should the bill pass, the cap on the number of schools would be lifted, and the 400 student per school enrollment cap would be increased to 1,000.
Other provisions in the bill include:
--Eliminating the requirement that cyber school students previously have been enrolled in a public school.
--Requiring cyber school operators to demonstrate experience delivering a program that improves student academic achievement. Currently, the state requires the applicant demonstrate experience in serving urban and at-risk student populations through an educational model involving a significant cyber component.
Proponents of SB 619 say the bill offers more options to students, as well as ties in strong use of technology.
Opponents to the measure say the cyber schools lack accountability and oversight, opens the door to "for-profits" to take Michigan education money our of the state. Opponents also question the bill's funding method.
The fight over SB 619 has been heated and is getting hotter as it appears a vote is nearer.
"Online instruction will only become a more important component of education in the future. Who knows, it may even become the primary means of learning," the editorial board of the Holland Sentinel wrote. "For now though, there just isn’t enough experience to go on to justify unlimited expansion of cyber schools with taxpayer dollars."
Proponents of SB 610 see it differently.
"This is a case of the education establishment in this state not wanting parents to have choices,” Education Committee chairman Thomas McMillin told MLive.com. “They want to be in control.”
Friday, January 27, 2012
North Carolina
The Cabarrus County Board of Education voted to give preliminary approval to a partnership with K12 Inc. to create North Carolina's first virtual charter school.
The school, the North Carolina Virtual Charter Academy, will be open to all North Carolina middle-school and high-school students. State education money would follow the students to the virtual charter school. In its application, the school district estimates it will take in $18 million worth of public funding within a few years.
According to Concord Independent Tribune, John Chisholm, vice president of school development for K12, Inc., told Cabarrus board members the virtual charter school would be staffed with North Carolina-certified teachers, and students would have online and hard copy school materials.
The Independent Tribune also reported that Chisholm also told the board that the charter for this new school would be submitted by North Carolina Learns, Inc., a proposed nonprofit group. The plan for the virtual charter school is allowed because of a new North Carolina law that eliminated the cap on charter schools. He said that going to a school district to partner with is one way for a charter school to receive initial approval.
The next step in the process is for the county's application to be sent to the North Carolina state Board of Education for approval.
For the last three months, debate has been intense over whether Cabarrus County should support a virtual charter school based in its school district.
Proponents included North Carolina State Sen. Fletcher Hartsell who told Cabarrus school board members the virtual charter academy an idea whose time has come with little risk and tremendous reward for the school system.
Opponents expressed wariness of allowing a for-profit company manage the virtual school. According the the blog "North Carolina Progressive Pulse," the Cabarrus school board's decision is a "move that would allow taxpayer money to flow to the questionable education company without significant oversight or public input."
In an editorial published by the South County Independent, editors said, "We suspect, however, that an all-electronic school would merely fragment students’ attention spans even further and lead us away from the intellectual rigor our schools desperately need."
Even with the school board's vote, it is not certain that the state board will give the virtual school final approval.
Cabarrus school district attorney Mark Henriques, who told local school board member members that he had spoken to Laura Crumpler, assistant attorney general at North Carolina Department of Justice who handles education issues, and Katie Cornetto, staff attorney for the State Board of Education. Crumpler and Cornetto said the state is still working on new guidelines and felt it would be unlikely that this or any other virtual charter school would get approved at the state level before those guidelines are developed, Henriques said.
North Carolina is already home to one of the largest virtual school populations in the United States. It is second only to Florida. Course enrollments in the state-lead North Carolina Virtual Public school is ) topped 70,000 at the end of 2010.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)