All it took to removed virtual education from Mississippi charter school legislation was a voice vote.
There appeared to be widespread support for strengthening the state's charter school law through Senate Bill 2401. In fact, the state full state Senate would later approve the bill. The Mississippi may vote on it by the beginning of March.
But it was a different matter for including virtual charter schools in the measure. Advocates of virtual charter schools didn't even get the satisfaction of finding out which legislators were on their side and which legislators were against virtual charters.
A voice vote to turn back virtual charter schools was all that was needed.
"This is the first step in the process," said Sen. David Blount, who offered the amendment to remove the virtual charter school component. He told the Northeast Mississippi Daily Journal that studies have shown in other states that the virtual charter schools have not been successful.
Senate Education Chair Gray Tollison disagreed. He argued that because of ever-changing technology language to allow online schools was needed in the bill.
Several stumbling blocks appear to have gotten in the way of inclusion of virtual charter schools in SB 2401.
Derrick Johnson, president of the Mississippi State Conference NAACP, told the Daily Mississippian the he believed virtual charter schools would take money from traditional public schools and send it to companies outside of the state. He also said they would be detrimental to the state economically and that the performance of virtual charter schools is worse than any other form of education in the country.
“Quality education should come before corporate profit,” Johnson said.
Mike Sayer, senior organizer and training coordinator for Southern Echo, a community development group that works in rural African-American communities, thinks charter schools would fail to provide a quality education to students.
“The record of virtual charter school is horrendous in terms of under-performing traditional public schools,” he said.
Southern Echo and the Mississippi NAACP chapter have also voiced concerns over expansion of brick-and-mortar charter schools.
But Rachel Canter, executive director of Mississippi First, a group that supports the charter school legislation, disagreed.
“I think that digital learning and virtual learning are here to stay,” she said. “The question is, ‘Is there a way to put in the bill to make sure that virtual school providers have to meet rigorous standards and that they are held accountable for the education they provide?’ An outright prohibition on virtual schools, I think, is probably not the best way to go about it.”
No comments:
Post a Comment