Monday, October 31, 2011

Michigan

Hours after the Michigan Senate approved a bill that would end caps on the number of virtual charter schools and lift restrictions on enrollment in the cyber charters, opponents of the measure launched a full-court press aimed at stopping the legislation.
The Michigan Education Association (MEA)  asked its members to urge their legislators to vote no on SB 619, the measure that would lift the restrictions. The Michigan Association of School Administrators, issued a statement that the proposal does not offer any guarantee of school quality. Superintendents of local school districts took to the hustings campaigning against the measure.
"I think more research has to be done to find out just how effective [online charter schools] are instead of just suddenly passing legislation -- at least at the Senate side -- in order to require unlimited access to this," Rockford Public Schools Superintendent Mike Shibler told WOOD-TV.
"Students certainly can benefit from cyber education or learning online, whether it be credit recovery or whether it be courses that are difficult to get otherwise from their local high school," the Rockford superintendent said. "But they also, I think, can benefit ... from actual 1-on-30, 1-on-25" relationships with teachers.
Opponents, including the MEA, contend that the cyber charters would be run by "private companies and would use public taxpayer dollars for funding. While this may be the legislature’s answer to 'education reform,' a report by University of Colorado education professors Gene V. Glass and Kevin G. Weiner criticizes the move because there is no high-quality evidence of their effectiveness," according to the MEA.
Oakland Schools Superintendent Vickie L. Markavitch encouraged parents to lobby their legislators not to support the sweeping reforms in a podcast posted on the Oakland Schools website earlier this month.
In the 12-minute video, Markavitch warned of unintended consequences that can’t be foreseen without proper research.
“Reform means change, and although no one ever intends to make things worse, the wrong reform and the wrong change can do just that,” she said. “There’s little evidence that those proposing reforms have even studied the research.”
But State Sen. Patrick Colbeck, a proponent of SB 619, said demand is driving the need to expand cyber charter school options. He said the two existing year-old cyber charter schools—where students in grades K-12 take all of their coursework online—have thousands of students on their waiting lists.
"I think it's going to be a game-changer for Michigan and our kids," said State Sen. Patrick Colbeck, who sponsored the cyber charter bill.
State Sen. Hoon-Yung Hopgood spoke for many of the opponents when he said the legislature is moving too fast. He said the current restrictions were put in place with the intent that they be lifted if, after two years, the schools demonstrated success. The schools opened in 2010, meaning the two-year mark won't be reached until this summer.
"It's really disappointing that we're just going to blow the caps off these schools when we don't have all the information on them," Hopgood said.
The cyber charter measure is part of an education reform package that would provide expanded opportunities for private school students to take public school classes; for public schools to provide programs for private schools, and for public and private students to enroll in both high school and community college at the same time.
The bills, part of a nine-bill package, now moves on to the House for consideration.

Friday, October 28, 2011

Virginia

The Virginia Association of School Superintendents have a plan for reformulating the state's goals for K-12 education and virtual education plays a significant role in the outline.
The plan, approved by the state's 133 superintendents, wants to see students become prepared for college and other post secondary education, and for careers.
The No.1 objective in the "Instructional Delivery" section of the plan is to online learning courses available to all Virginia students. To do this, according to the report, Virginia needs to "provide funding to support virtual programs in the form of materials, hardware, software, space, and personnel to school divisions in order that all schools, regardless of size, can offer instructional alternatives to students."
The plan also wants the state to take a new look at seat-time requirements.
A proponent of the plan, Gloucester County Superintendent Howard B. "Ben" Kiser said the evolution of technology and virtual learning caused the superintendents to rethink time in education, according to the Richmond Times Dispatch.
"We know through virtual curriculum … students do not have to sit in a class for 140 hours (and) 180 school days," he told the Times Dispatch.
The Virginia Education Association did not immediately take a position on the plan. Earlier this month, the teachers union urged Gov. Bob McDOnnell to make K-12 education a funding priority.

Monday, October 17, 2011

Michigan

Three members of the Michigan Board of Education asked lawmakers to vote against proposals that would lift caps on the number of virtual charter schools in the state.
The three members – Marianne McGuire, Kathleen Straus, and Casandra Ulbrich – took an unusual step of issuing a statement after opposing a proposed open letter about the reforms at the October state school board meeting. The trio also said they were also against creating a "parent trigger" that would allow conversion of public schools into charters.
This is the latest volley in a pitched battle over education reform.
Earlier this month, the Michigan state senate approved a measure that allows the expansion of charter and cyber charter schools.The bill removes a cap on the number of schools authorized by state universities and also makes it easier for successful out-of-state charter school operators to supervise school in Michigan.
The bill has been sent to the Michigan House and is part of a seven-bill package that aims to increase choice for public school students and their parents.
Proponents say Michigan parents need choices so children can escape failing schools and that greater choice greater will foster more competition which will forces all schools to improve.
Opponents, ranging from the Michigan Education Association to legislative Democrats, argue the measures help charter schools while stripping traditional public schools of necessary funding.
"All we're doing is subsidizing these for-profit ventures and diverting scarce resources from our neighborhood, locally governed public schools," Democratic state Sen. Hoon-Yung Hopgood told the Associated Press.
The three board of education members said they wanted to retain the cap on cyber charters because there isn't enough data to show if these types of schools are effective.
Instead of the proposed reforms, the three board members said the way to improve Michigan's public schools included improving access to early childhood programs, reducing class sizes, and removing incentives to reduce the number of school days.

Tuesday, October 4, 2011

Tennessee

When the Tennessee legislature approved the Public Virtual School Act earlier this year, and when Gov. Bill Haslam signed it into law, did these lawmakers put the cart before the horse?
That's what the state board of education will try to determine later this month when it meets to establish rules and guidelines for virtual schools.
That's right, Tennessee has a new virtual school law that went into effect on July 1. It even has a new K-8 virtual school, the Tennessee Virtual Academy (TNVA) that opened its doors this fall. But the state doesn't have any rules or guidelines that governing the operation of virtual schools.
That may all change in the next few weeks, and there will be a fight over the rules.
Proponents of the Public Virtual School Act say the new law will help move Tennessee to the forefront of the education reform movement. They add that bumps are to be expected with the introduction of anything new.
Bumps there were when TNVA opened its doors this fall. There were enrollment glitches, problems getting students the hardware and software they needed for classes, and a lot of bruised feelings when traditional school districts lost students to the tiny Union County Public Schools, which contracted with K12 Inc. for online school services.
"We believe the Tennessee Virtual Academy will be an excellent choice for children who need personalized learning programs," said Wayne Goforth, director of schools for Union County Public Schools. "Our school district is focused on providing the best education we can to all of our students. This online school is another opportunity for us to be innovative and responsive to the education needs of every child."
Opponents aren't so sure. Critics say K12 Inc., through lobbyists, pushed a virtual-school bill through to passage in the closing minutes of the state legislature. They say money precious school funding is flowing out of Tennessee and into Virginia, where K12 Inc. is based.
"I don’t think the state is looking out for the child’s best interest," Dickson County school board member Steve Haley said. "I think they are looking at private companies’ interest." Dickson lost 24 students to TNVA. Since the Public Virtual School Act allows state funds to follow students, Dickson County schools lost nearly $81,000 – or roughly $4,300 per student – to K12 and Union County.
According to the Nashville Tennessean, Gov. Haslam, said recently that he's just now learning its full impact.
"I'm growing increasingly familiar with it. It's something I want to understand the ramifications a lot better. I understand how (virtual education) could be very beneficial; you could offer subjects that aren't offered other places. But I do think we have to think through the consequences a little bit more than we've done so far."
That's what the Tennessee Board of Education will try to do in October.