Can Florida's fast-growing online class enrollment survive Amendment 8, a ballot measure that will determine the future of K-12 class size, on the November 2010 Florida ballot?
Florida voters were clear in 2002--they wanted to limit the size of public school classes. No more than 18 students in pre-kindergarten through third grade, 22 in fourth through eighth grade and 25 in high school.
This directive was phased in and finally fully implemented at the beginning 2010 school year. That's when the impact was felt. Principals scrambled to make to meet the mandate. They had to--for every student over the maximum, the school would have to pay a fine of $3,000 per
student.
However, there was one seemingly unintended benefit of the class size vote: online classes grew rapidly. From Miami to Tallahassee, from Tampa Bay, to Melbourne, schools channeled more and more students to online courses. The reason: There is no limit on the number of students in online classes.
The students jumped at the opportunity to take some of their classes online.
Andrew Helms, a Florida high school junior, expressed his enthusiasm at the offer of taking World History online when his school had no classroom seats
available for him.
"It's like college at home," Andrew told Tampbay.com. He plans to take the course in the evenings and use his open class period to complete other school assignments.
"I like working on computers."
Basically, Amendment 8 asks voters to change the current class size maximums to
"school-wide average" class size. According to the proponents, this change would bring about "flexibility" for schools.
Amendment 8 opponents say the current battle is really about funding because it's expected to save $350 million to $1 billion in class-size costs every year. The opponents say since Amendment 8 does not guarantee that the savings will go back to schools, the proposed law is a way to stop fully funding public schools and increase class size.
If Florida voters decided to stick with the current class size rules, enrollment in online classes is sure to grow, and grow fast.
If voters decide "flexibility" is better, enrollment in online course may grow, but not as fast.
Tuesday, October 19, 2010
Monday, October 11, 2010
Pennsylvania
Pennsylvania Auditor General Jack Wagner fired the first volley. He called for a moratorium on creation of cyber-charter and charter schools until a new state funding system is in place. According to Wagner, the current funding system has serious inequities in how tax money is used to finance these public school alternatives.
Reaction was swift.Newspaper editorial took competing sides of the issue. The York Dispatch praised Wagner's stand. The moratorium is the right thing to do, the editorial board wrote, because overhauling the funding system is "long overdue.
On the other side, the Pittsburgh Tribune said Wagner's idea of a moratorium was "charter school claptrap."
"There would be no "issue" over districts' tuition payments if the alternative to public education's status quo wasn't in fact nibbling away at the edutocracy's lunch," wrote the editorial board.
Leading Pennsylvania educators were quick to defend--and denounce--Wagner's proposal.
Ron Sofo — superintendent of Freedom Area School District — said “in tough economic times — when everybody’s scraping to get by — you have to find a system that’s more fiscally responsible to everyone.”
Nick Trombetta — chief executive officer at the Midland-based Pennsylvania Cyber Charter School — said the present system “expects us to do as much (as a public school) with less (money per student) — and we’ve been doing a reasonably good job with it at PA Cyber — so I don’t see where we’re the problem.”
Reaction was swift.Newspaper editorial took competing sides of the issue. The York Dispatch praised Wagner's stand. The moratorium is the right thing to do, the editorial board wrote, because overhauling the funding system is "long overdue.
On the other side, the Pittsburgh Tribune said Wagner's idea of a moratorium was "charter school claptrap."
"There would be no "issue" over districts' tuition payments if the alternative to public education's status quo wasn't in fact nibbling away at the edutocracy's lunch," wrote the editorial board.
Leading Pennsylvania educators were quick to defend--and denounce--Wagner's proposal.
Ron Sofo — superintendent of Freedom Area School District — said “in tough economic times — when everybody’s scraping to get by — you have to find a system that’s more fiscally responsible to everyone.”
Nick Trombetta — chief executive officer at the Midland-based Pennsylvania Cyber Charter School — said the present system “expects us to do as much (as a public school) with less (money per student) — and we’ve been doing a reasonably good job with it at PA Cyber — so I don’t see where we’re the problem.”
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)