Tuesday, March 29, 2011
Florida
The National Coalition for Public School Options has issued a called to the Florida Legislature to increase access to public virtual education by approving Senate Bill 1620. Florida is a leader in the virtual education movement and is home to the nation's largest state-led virtual school, the Florida Virtual School. Still, the National Coalition for Public School Options says Florida could create more options for online learning. SB 1620, the organization says, would do that. Among the things SB 1620 would do, it would add statewide virtual providers to the list of public school choices; it would provide state funding for virtual charter schools; it would provides creation of blended-learning charter schools; and it would allow home-schooled students to enroll in certain virtual education courses offered in the school district in which they reside. "The districts do not promote their programs, limit access, and are looking for low cost providers so they can pocket the savings. In Florida's largest district, Miami-Dade, with nearly 400,000 total enrollments, fewer than 100 students are enrolled in their online school program. In Broward County, a district official recently sent an email notifying parents that he opposes SB 1620 because his program had no interest in competing for enrollments and having to expend the resources necessary to have a competitive program. Relying on district programs is not a workable model if our focus is on students and the goal is access to quality full time online public schools," according to Wendy Howard, Chairwoman of the Florida Chapter of the National Coalition for Public School Options. "Open access to numerous options has proven successful in over 20 other states," adds Howard. "In the past two years, full-time enrollments in Georgia have grown to 6,000 students, South Carolina to 4,500, while in Florida we have seen little growth in the number of enrollments. If Florida is to realize the promise of online learning, it must adopt these effective models that give parents more choices of state approved online schools."
Friday, March 25, 2011
Wisconsin
New battle lines are being drawn in Wisconsin. This time the fight is over lifting the enrollment cap on virtual charter schools.
Republican state senators say they are ready to lift the 5,250-student enrollment cap on virtual charter schools in the state. Senate Bill 22, which had its first public hearing in the Senate Education Committee this week, eliminates the cap.
The Republicans who support the measure, including Senate Education Committee Chairman Luther Olsen, are not alone. State schools chief Tony Evers favors removing the cap. So does Gov. Rick Scott, who has pledged to sign an enrollment cap removal measure into law.
Opponents to the bill say lifting the cap will unleash many unanticipated problems. Schools chief Evers disagrees.
Removing the caps on virtual schools or the choice program would not "fundamentally change the way those programs operate, nor will it dramatically increase the enrollments," Evers said.
Wisconsin had 3,927 students enrolled in 13 full-time online charter schools in school year 2009-2010; this was a 26% increase from the previous year.
The state’s largest teachers’ union says it’s not opposed to dropping the cap – as long as the state looks at quality issues for those schools, and revisits the funding of virtual schools as part of the open enrollment program.
Critics of SB 22 say if the cap comes off small districts, in particular, could suffer if significant numbers of students enroll in virtual schools and take their state aid with them.
Dan Rossmiller of the Wisconsin Association of School Boards said his organization opposes the bill for several reasons. One reason is that school districts that have no charter schools will be forced to help subsidize charters in other communities through these losses in general state aid for schools.
"With the state in a budget crisis, this is not the time to be dividing scarce public resources and tax dollars to other entities that operate outside the traditional democratic process," he says.
A similar bill has been introduced in the Wisconsin Assembly. No date has been set for a vote on either measure.
Republican state senators say they are ready to lift the 5,250-student enrollment cap on virtual charter schools in the state. Senate Bill 22, which had its first public hearing in the Senate Education Committee this week, eliminates the cap.
The Republicans who support the measure, including Senate Education Committee Chairman Luther Olsen, are not alone. State schools chief Tony Evers favors removing the cap. So does Gov. Rick Scott, who has pledged to sign an enrollment cap removal measure into law.
Opponents to the bill say lifting the cap will unleash many unanticipated problems. Schools chief Evers disagrees.
Removing the caps on virtual schools or the choice program would not "fundamentally change the way those programs operate, nor will it dramatically increase the enrollments," Evers said.
Wisconsin had 3,927 students enrolled in 13 full-time online charter schools in school year 2009-2010; this was a 26% increase from the previous year.
The state’s largest teachers’ union says it’s not opposed to dropping the cap – as long as the state looks at quality issues for those schools, and revisits the funding of virtual schools as part of the open enrollment program.
Critics of SB 22 say if the cap comes off small districts, in particular, could suffer if significant numbers of students enroll in virtual schools and take their state aid with them.
Dan Rossmiller of the Wisconsin Association of School Boards said his organization opposes the bill for several reasons. One reason is that school districts that have no charter schools will be forced to help subsidize charters in other communities through these losses in general state aid for schools.
"With the state in a budget crisis, this is not the time to be dividing scarce public resources and tax dollars to other entities that operate outside the traditional democratic process," he says.
A similar bill has been introduced in the Wisconsin Assembly. No date has been set for a vote on either measure.
Monday, March 21, 2011
Indiana
This week Indiana may take another step toward a plan that would streamline its complex regulations for virtual charter schools, and ultimately may lead to virtual charter schools to qualify to receive state money.
In 2005, Indiana officials authorized a pilot program for virtual charter schools under the auspices of the Indiana Virtual Pilot Schools (IVPS). This experiment, however, did not allow state money to go to virtual charters.
Even without state money, Indiana has two thriving virtual charter schools, Indiana Connections Academy Virtual Pilot School and Hoosier Academy–Virtual Pilot School.
At the end of the 2009 school year, the legislative ban state money going to virtual charter schools ended.
Backers of virtual education say that since charter schools are public schools, they should receive state funding just like traditional public schools
The measure now moving through the Indiana legislature, HB 1002, states that beginning in the 2011-2012 school year, virtual charter schools will be entitled to state money that equals 80-90% of state funding for public schools. What's more, the bill ends the virtual charter school pilot program, allows existing virtual charter schools to seek sponsors, and paves the way for creation of new virtual charter schools.
The Indiana House has approved the bill. So has the Senate's Education Committee. This week HB 1002 faces a crucial test in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
In 2005, Indiana officials authorized a pilot program for virtual charter schools under the auspices of the Indiana Virtual Pilot Schools (IVPS). This experiment, however, did not allow state money to go to virtual charters.
Even without state money, Indiana has two thriving virtual charter schools, Indiana Connections Academy Virtual Pilot School and Hoosier Academy–Virtual Pilot School.
At the end of the 2009 school year, the legislative ban state money going to virtual charter schools ended.
Backers of virtual education say that since charter schools are public schools, they should receive state funding just like traditional public schools
The measure now moving through the Indiana legislature, HB 1002, states that beginning in the 2011-2012 school year, virtual charter schools will be entitled to state money that equals 80-90% of state funding for public schools. What's more, the bill ends the virtual charter school pilot program, allows existing virtual charter schools to seek sponsors, and paves the way for creation of new virtual charter schools.
The Indiana House has approved the bill. So has the Senate's Education Committee. This week HB 1002 faces a crucial test in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
Monday, March 14, 2011
Montana
There are no virtual charter schools in Montana. There are no charter schools in the state. Why? Because Montana does not have a charter school law.
That may all change if HB 603 is approved.
"Provide for Public Charter Schools" is the name of the bill that is scheduled for a hearing before the House Education Committee this week. Basically, the measure allows for fully funded virtual charters including competency-based alternatives to seat time.
Charter holders will be nonprofit organizations. The bill a charter board can hold multiple charters.
Montanans have wanted charters for some time. A 2008 survey reported that 9 out of 10 voters wanted the option to "send their children to a private, charter, or virtual schools, or educate their children in a home school setting."
These strong feelings may be one reason Montana's home-school community is backing HB 603.
The School Administrators of Montana is one of the groups opposing the bill. They believe that charter schools, and virtual charters, will drain resources and students away from traditional public schools.
That may all change if HB 603 is approved.
"Provide for Public Charter Schools" is the name of the bill that is scheduled for a hearing before the House Education Committee this week. Basically, the measure allows for fully funded virtual charters including competency-based alternatives to seat time.
Charter holders will be nonprofit organizations. The bill a charter board can hold multiple charters.
Montanans have wanted charters for some time. A 2008 survey reported that 9 out of 10 voters wanted the option to "send their children to a private, charter, or virtual schools, or educate their children in a home school setting."
These strong feelings may be one reason Montana's home-school community is backing HB 603.
The School Administrators of Montana is one of the groups opposing the bill. They believe that charter schools, and virtual charters, will drain resources and students away from traditional public schools.
Thursday, March 10, 2011
Utah
After a roller coaster ride, the Utah House approved SB 65, which allows state money to follow students who enroll in online classes and virtual charter schools.
At least some online classes and some virtual charter schools.
The House version of the bill allows state money to go to public online courses and virtual charters. House lawmakers removed language that would have allowed state money to follow students no matter what online programs, even private and parochial programs, they attended.
This version of SB 65 must now be reconciled with the version that was approved in the Utah Senate. In the Senate version, state money can go to public and private virtual education programs.
The House version of SB 65 also lowers the amount of money that online course providers can receive from about $900 per class to about $700 for each class. Additionally, about 50 percent of that money is received upfront and 50 percent received after a student successfully
completes a course.
SB 65 backers seem to be supportive of the narrowed funding focus. Michael B. Horn, a Liberating Learning blog contributor and co-author of "Disrupting Class: How Disruptive Innovation Will change the Way the World Learns," called the changes "reasonable."
"Ultimately this bill still aligns to the "10 Elements of High Quality Digital Learning" outlined in Digital Learning Now, and as such, represents a bold move away from the monolithic, factory model schools of our past and a big step forward toward a more student-centric future that allows students to have personalized options for their learning based in their distinct needs," Horn wrote.
At least some online classes and some virtual charter schools.
The House version of the bill allows state money to go to public online courses and virtual charters. House lawmakers removed language that would have allowed state money to follow students no matter what online programs, even private and parochial programs, they attended.
This version of SB 65 must now be reconciled with the version that was approved in the Utah Senate. In the Senate version, state money can go to public and private virtual education programs.
The House version of SB 65 also lowers the amount of money that online course providers can receive from about $900 per class to about $700 for each class. Additionally, about 50 percent of that money is received upfront and 50 percent received after a student successfully
completes a course.
SB 65 backers seem to be supportive of the narrowed funding focus. Michael B. Horn, a Liberating Learning blog contributor and co-author of "Disrupting Class: How Disruptive Innovation Will change the Way the World Learns," called the changes "reasonable."
"Ultimately this bill still aligns to the "10 Elements of High Quality Digital Learning" outlined in Digital Learning Now, and as such, represents a bold move away from the monolithic, factory model schools of our past and a big step forward toward a more student-centric future that allows students to have personalized options for their learning based in their distinct needs," Horn wrote.
Wednesday, March 9, 2011
Utah
Some of the virtual education movements big dogs weighed in in Utah's continuing battle over expanding virtual education opportunities for K-12 students.
Former governors Jeb Bush and Bob Wise, who co-founded Digital Learning Now, a virtual education advocacy group, wrote in an op-ed directed at Utah legislators that their group pledged to "assist states with integrating current and future technological innovations into K-12 public education."
In the Deseret News, Clayton Christensen, co-author of "Disrupting Class: How Disruptive Innovation Will change the Way the World Learns," challenged the legislators.
"If our goal is to educate every student to the highest potential, then schools need to move away
from this monolithic classroom model and toward a student-centric educational one with a modular design that enables mass customization," he wrote.
The push for support of expansion of Utah's online education programs comes after a roller coaster ride for a bill that would allow state money to follow students who take online classes offered by public and private providers.
When the legislation, SB 65, or the "Statewide Online Education Program" first came up for a vote earlier this month, opponents said the the $700,000 price tag was too expensive. Others called it a stealth school voucher bill because state money could go to private online course providers instead of to public schools.
The measure was defeated.
In fast turnaround, SB 65 was placed back on the full Senate's calendar later the same day and mustered enough support for a new vote on March. 2.
This time, the bill was approved.
SB 65 now is in the Utah Assembly awaiting committee assignment and hearing.
Not everyone is in favor of SB 65. An editorial in the Salt Lake Tribune stated flatly, "SB 65 would send taxpayer money to private online schools, instead of funding public online courses."
However, in his editorial, Christensen called on the legislators to create an open marketplace for online education.
"By creating competition between providers based on delivering positive student outcomes — and freeing up the process by which they get there — Utah has a significant opportunity to drive this innovation forward by leaps and bounds," he wrote.
Govs. Bush and Wise added, "With online and digital learning, Utah high school students will be able to customize their education to better meet their academic goals and prepare them for post-secondary education, vocational and careers. More options, better outcomes, reduced costs—it’s a great deal for Utah’s students, schools, and taxpayers."
Former governors Jeb Bush and Bob Wise, who co-founded Digital Learning Now, a virtual education advocacy group, wrote in an op-ed directed at Utah legislators that their group pledged to "assist states with integrating current and future technological innovations into K-12 public education."
In the Deseret News, Clayton Christensen, co-author of "Disrupting Class: How Disruptive Innovation Will change the Way the World Learns," challenged the legislators.
"If our goal is to educate every student to the highest potential, then schools need to move away
from this monolithic classroom model and toward a student-centric educational one with a modular design that enables mass customization," he wrote.
The push for support of expansion of Utah's online education programs comes after a roller coaster ride for a bill that would allow state money to follow students who take online classes offered by public and private providers.
When the legislation, SB 65, or the "Statewide Online Education Program" first came up for a vote earlier this month, opponents said the the $700,000 price tag was too expensive. Others called it a stealth school voucher bill because state money could go to private online course providers instead of to public schools.
The measure was defeated.
In fast turnaround, SB 65 was placed back on the full Senate's calendar later the same day and mustered enough support for a new vote on March. 2.
This time, the bill was approved.
SB 65 now is in the Utah Assembly awaiting committee assignment and hearing.
Not everyone is in favor of SB 65. An editorial in the Salt Lake Tribune stated flatly, "SB 65 would send taxpayer money to private online schools, instead of funding public online courses."
However, in his editorial, Christensen called on the legislators to create an open marketplace for online education.
"By creating competition between providers based on delivering positive student outcomes — and freeing up the process by which they get there — Utah has a significant opportunity to drive this innovation forward by leaps and bounds," he wrote.
Govs. Bush and Wise added, "With online and digital learning, Utah high school students will be able to customize their education to better meet their academic goals and prepare them for post-secondary education, vocational and careers. More options, better outcomes, reduced costs—it’s a great deal for Utah’s students, schools, and taxpayers."
Monday, March 7, 2011
Pennsylvania
Opportunity scholarships. That's what Pennsylvania state Sens. Anthony Williams, a Democrat, and Jeffrey Piccola, a Republican, call their legislation to allow low-income students at failing schools to take state-allocated money with them to virtual schools, private schools, magnet schools, schools outside of their district, whatever educational facility their family believes will serve them best.
"Stealth vouchers" is what opponents call the plan. This fight over funding-following the student is being played out throughout the country. Similar measures have been introduced in Oregon and Nevada and Utah.
The focus this week is in Pennsylvania where "Opportunity Scholarship and Education Improvement Tax Credit," aka SB 1, is being debated.
Last week, the state Senate Education Committee voted 8-2 to approve SB 1. The bill's next stop is the state Senate Appropriations Committee.
Finding alternative funding solutions for Pennsylvania's cyber-charters and charter schools is a hot-button issues and critical for their continued growth.
In late 2010, state Auditor Gen. Jack Wagner said there should be a moratorium on creation of cyber-charter and charter schools until a new state funding system is in place. According to Wagner, the current funding system has serious inequities in how tax money is used to finance these public school alternatives.
Since his announcement, proposals for cyber-charters have slowed.
That's one reason SB 1 is getting so much attention. It is also, gathering support.
At his March 7 confirmation hearing, acting Education Secretary Ron Tomalis threw his backing behind SB 1. According to the Pittsburgh Post-Dispatch, Tomalis said He said state public school districts now are seeing a generation of parents who grew up with a variety of consumer choices, and many expect the same in their child's education options.
"Their entire existence has been about choice, consumer choice, choosing what works best for them, and part of the learning process is how to make a very intelligent, and the best, decision for them," said Tomalis.
SB 1 has generated intense debate and created new alliances. The International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers, IBEW 98 has joined with former House Majority Leader Dick Armey's Freedomworks to support the measure.
On the other side, Pennsylvania's Education Law Center, a non-profit legal advocacy and educational organization, which says it is dedicated to ensuring that all of Pennsylvania’s children have access to a quality public education, has come out against the bill.
"Our single measuring stick for SB 1 and all education policy proposals is whether the suggested reform is in the best interest of disadvantaged students, families, and communities throughout Pennsylvania. Senate Bill 1 fails this test. It is not designed to maximize help for the neediest students," according to the ELC report.
The Pennsylvania School Boards Association and the Pennsylvania State Education Association are opposed to SB 1. In testimony before the Senate Education Committee today, PSBA Executive Director Thomas J. Gentzel called taxpayer-funded tuition vouchers unaccountable, unaffordable, unpopular, unproven and unconstitutional.
Bill co-sponsor Williams wrote that the opponents arguments are the same as they were 15 years ago when Gov. Tom Ridge introduce a voucher program to support school choice.
"Our opponents seem more concerned with propping up a system than educating children. They cling to the antiquated belief that existing public school systems have the right of first refusal when it comes to educating our children. An innovative and productive public education system can include home schooling, parochial schools, private schools, cyber schools, public charter schools and, yes, traditional public schools — all of which I support," said Williams.
"Stealth vouchers" is what opponents call the plan. This fight over funding-following the student is being played out throughout the country. Similar measures have been introduced in Oregon and Nevada and Utah.
The focus this week is in Pennsylvania where "Opportunity Scholarship and Education Improvement Tax Credit," aka SB 1, is being debated.
Last week, the state Senate Education Committee voted 8-2 to approve SB 1. The bill's next stop is the state Senate Appropriations Committee.
Finding alternative funding solutions for Pennsylvania's cyber-charters and charter schools is a hot-button issues and critical for their continued growth.
In late 2010, state Auditor Gen. Jack Wagner said there should be a moratorium on creation of cyber-charter and charter schools until a new state funding system is in place. According to Wagner, the current funding system has serious inequities in how tax money is used to finance these public school alternatives.
Since his announcement, proposals for cyber-charters have slowed.
That's one reason SB 1 is getting so much attention. It is also, gathering support.
At his March 7 confirmation hearing, acting Education Secretary Ron Tomalis threw his backing behind SB 1. According to the Pittsburgh Post-Dispatch, Tomalis said He said state public school districts now are seeing a generation of parents who grew up with a variety of consumer choices, and many expect the same in their child's education options.
"Their entire existence has been about choice, consumer choice, choosing what works best for them, and part of the learning process is how to make a very intelligent, and the best, decision for them," said Tomalis.
SB 1 has generated intense debate and created new alliances. The International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers, IBEW 98 has joined with former House Majority Leader Dick Armey's Freedomworks to support the measure.
On the other side, Pennsylvania's Education Law Center, a non-profit legal advocacy and educational organization, which says it is dedicated to ensuring that all of Pennsylvania’s children have access to a quality public education, has come out against the bill.
"Our single measuring stick for SB 1 and all education policy proposals is whether the suggested reform is in the best interest of disadvantaged students, families, and communities throughout Pennsylvania. Senate Bill 1 fails this test. It is not designed to maximize help for the neediest students," according to the ELC report.
The Pennsylvania School Boards Association and the Pennsylvania State Education Association are opposed to SB 1. In testimony before the Senate Education Committee today, PSBA Executive Director Thomas J. Gentzel called taxpayer-funded tuition vouchers unaccountable, unaffordable, unpopular, unproven and unconstitutional.
Bill co-sponsor Williams wrote that the opponents arguments are the same as they were 15 years ago when Gov. Tom Ridge introduce a voucher program to support school choice.
"Our opponents seem more concerned with propping up a system than educating children. They cling to the antiquated belief that existing public school systems have the right of first refusal when it comes to educating our children. An innovative and productive public education system can include home schooling, parochial schools, private schools, cyber schools, public charter schools and, yes, traditional public schools — all of which I support," said Williams.
Friday, March 4, 2011
Utah
What a difference a day makes when it comes to expanding online school opportunities in Utah.
On March 1, the Utah State Senate voted down SB 65, a bill that would allow state money to follow students who take online classes offered by public and private providers.
Yes, in some cases this would create competition for Utah's state-led Electronic High School, but some legislators said competition in the education arena is a good thing.
"Right now students are not able to take courses a la carte from anybody except the monopoly at the State Office of Education, the bill's sponsor Sen. Howard Stephenson, told the Salt Lake Tribune. "I think that’s wrong. ... I think it’s time we move into the 21st century with
this process."
On March 2, the situation changed.
The Utah state Senate voted 17-12 in favor of the plan.
The legislation was sent to the House, where it was introduced and awaits committee assignment.
When SB 65, or the "Statewide Online Education Program" bill first came up for a vote, opponents said the the $700,000 price tag was too expensive. Others called it a stealth school voucher bill because state money could go to private online course providers instead of to
public schools.
The bill's early defeat brought out supporters such as Michael B. Horn, author of "Disrupting Class: How Disruptive Innovation Will Change the Way the World Learns," and a contributor to the Liberating Learning Blog.
Horn challenged Utah legislators to "to transform the state's education system by prioritizing the success of each individual student, which will catapult the state ahead of the rest of the nation."
To those who worried that state money would be sent to private firms that cared more about revenue than student performance, Horn pointed out, "online course providers would only receive a significant portion — 40 percent — of the total funding if the student successfully
completed the course. This is a level of accountability that has never been seen before in education."
In fast turnaround, SB 65 was placed back on the full Senate's calendar later the same day and mustered enough support for a new vote on March. 2
"This is a wonderful opportunity to explore yet another way to educate our children through the private sector,” Sen. Stuart Reid told the Salt Lake City Tribune.
On March 1, the Utah State Senate voted down SB 65, a bill that would allow state money to follow students who take online classes offered by public and private providers.
Yes, in some cases this would create competition for Utah's state-led Electronic High School, but some legislators said competition in the education arena is a good thing.
"Right now students are not able to take courses a la carte from anybody except the monopoly at the State Office of Education, the bill's sponsor Sen. Howard Stephenson, told the Salt Lake Tribune. "I think that’s wrong. ... I think it’s time we move into the 21st century with
this process."
On March 2, the situation changed.
The Utah state Senate voted 17-12 in favor of the plan.
The legislation was sent to the House, where it was introduced and awaits committee assignment.
When SB 65, or the "Statewide Online Education Program" bill first came up for a vote, opponents said the the $700,000 price tag was too expensive. Others called it a stealth school voucher bill because state money could go to private online course providers instead of to
public schools.
The bill's early defeat brought out supporters such as Michael B. Horn, author of "Disrupting Class: How Disruptive Innovation Will Change the Way the World Learns," and a contributor to the Liberating Learning Blog.
Horn challenged Utah legislators to "to transform the state's education system by prioritizing the success of each individual student, which will catapult the state ahead of the rest of the nation."
To those who worried that state money would be sent to private firms that cared more about revenue than student performance, Horn pointed out, "online course providers would only receive a significant portion — 40 percent — of the total funding if the student successfully
completed the course. This is a level of accountability that has never been seen before in education."
In fast turnaround, SB 65 was placed back on the full Senate's calendar later the same day and mustered enough support for a new vote on March. 2
"This is a wonderful opportunity to explore yet another way to educate our children through the private sector,” Sen. Stuart Reid told the Salt Lake City Tribune.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)