Opportunity scholarships. That's what Pennsylvania state Sens. Anthony Williams, a Democrat, and Jeffrey Piccola, a Republican, call their legislation to allow low-income students at failing schools to take state-allocated money with them to virtual schools, private schools, magnet schools, schools outside of their district, whatever educational facility their family believes will serve them best.
"Stealth vouchers" is what opponents call the plan. This fight over funding-following the student is being played out throughout the country. Similar measures have been introduced in Oregon and Nevada and Utah.
The focus this week is in Pennsylvania where "Opportunity Scholarship and Education Improvement Tax Credit," aka SB 1, is being debated.
Last week, the state Senate Education Committee voted 8-2 to approve SB 1. The bill's next stop is the state Senate Appropriations Committee.
Finding alternative funding solutions for Pennsylvania's cyber-charters and charter schools is a hot-button issues and critical for their continued growth.
In late 2010, state Auditor Gen. Jack Wagner said there should be a moratorium on creation of cyber-charter and charter schools until a new state funding system is in place. According to Wagner, the current funding system has serious inequities in how tax money is used to finance these public school alternatives.
Since his announcement, proposals for cyber-charters have slowed.
That's one reason SB 1 is getting so much attention. It is also, gathering support.
At his March 7 confirmation hearing, acting Education Secretary Ron Tomalis threw his backing behind SB 1. According to the Pittsburgh Post-Dispatch, Tomalis said He said state public school districts now are seeing a generation of parents who grew up with a variety of consumer choices, and many expect the same in their child's education options.
"Their entire existence has been about choice, consumer choice, choosing what works best for them, and part of the learning process is how to make a very intelligent, and the best, decision for them," said Tomalis.
SB 1 has generated intense debate and created new alliances. The International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers, IBEW 98 has joined with former House Majority Leader Dick Armey's Freedomworks to support the measure.
On the other side, Pennsylvania's Education Law Center, a non-profit legal advocacy and educational organization, which says it is dedicated to ensuring that all of Pennsylvania’s children have access to a quality public education, has come out against the bill.
"Our single measuring stick for SB 1 and all education policy proposals is whether the suggested reform is in the best interest of disadvantaged students, families, and communities throughout Pennsylvania. Senate Bill 1 fails this test. It is not designed to maximize help for the neediest students," according to the ELC report.
The Pennsylvania School Boards Association and the Pennsylvania State Education Association are opposed to SB 1. In testimony before the Senate Education Committee today, PSBA Executive Director Thomas J. Gentzel called taxpayer-funded tuition vouchers unaccountable, unaffordable, unpopular, unproven and unconstitutional.
Bill co-sponsor Williams wrote that the opponents arguments are the same as they were 15 years ago when Gov. Tom Ridge introduce a voucher program to support school choice.
"Our opponents seem more concerned with propping up a system than educating children. They cling to the antiquated belief that existing public school systems have the right of first refusal when it comes to educating our children. An innovative and productive public education system can include home schooling, parochial schools, private schools, cyber schools, public charter schools and, yes, traditional public schools — all of which I support," said Williams.
No comments:
Post a Comment