Thursday, December 29, 2011

Michigan


It looks as if a decision on lifting the cap on cyber schools in Michigan will happen sometime in 2012.
Some thought that SB 619 would be approved and signed into law by the end of 2011. That's what happened with it's companion bill, SB 618, which lifted the cap on the number of charter schools.
But as the old year moved to a close, SB 619, was stalled in the the Michigan House education committee and isn't expected to be voted on until the new year.
The measure has already been approved by the Michigan Senate.
Currently, there are two cyber schools in Michigan with an enrollment of 400 students each. Should the bill pass, the cap on the number of schools would be lifted, and the 400 student per school enrollment cap would be increased to 1,000.
Other provisions in the bill include:
--Eliminating the requirement that cyber school students previously have been enrolled in a public school.
--Requiring  cyber school operators to demonstrate experience delivering a program that improves student academic achievement. Currently, the state requires the applicant demonstrate experience in serving urban and at-risk student populations through an educational model involving a significant cyber component.
Proponents of SB 619 say the bill believe it offers more options to students, as well as ties in strong use of technology.
State Representative Tom McMillin, who  chairs the House Education Committee, told Michigan Public Radio that he and many other lawmakers are impressed with the ability of cyber schools to help kids who struggle in traditional public schools, or drop out.
"It has blown us away, I mean it’s extremely impressive. I think it’s going to be, once people see what it’s producing, what the results are, they get all excited about it,” McMillan said.
Opponents to the measure say the cyber schools lack accountability and oversight and question the funding method.
A post on "Blogging for Michigan" stated that, "The Michigan Virtual Charter Academy that made a presentation at the Dec. 6 House committee meeting failed to meet Adequate Yearly Progress (AYP) during their one year of operation, and that was not brought out. Apparently, the school only tested less than 80 percent of their students instead of the required 95 percent. That requirement is in place so a school cannot cherry pick and only have their best students take the  Michigan Educational Assessment Program test (MEAP)."
"This bill, along with Senate Bill 618 that lifts the cap on charter schools, is just a thinly disguised attempt to privatize public education and bust teacher unions," the post continued.
Michigan Republicans leaders in the GOP-dominated legislature say they want to allow more K-12 cyber schools. GOP Gov. Rick Scott says he will sign any bill lifting the cap into law. But everything is on hold until the new year.

Friday, December 9, 2011

California


A coalition of California school districts, county offices of education and statewide education associations are taking a new tact when it comes to the battle over expansion of K-12 online learning.
This could be one of the first volleys in a change of strategy that is starting to gain adherents among teachers unions and in other parts of the education establishment.
These groups no longer want to be seen as just saying no to digital learning initiatives. Instead, they are starting to develop their own criteria for implementation of digital learning and creation of virtual charter and virtual schools. In some cases, the education establishment's methods are seen as delaying tactics.
In California, an organization that calls itself the "K-12 Education Management Group" has issued a set of seven principles it says are needed for a statewide digital learning policy can be put into place.
"The Department of Education, Department of Finance and key legislative staffers are skeptical that if the kid's not in a room with a teacher, they're not sure what level of learning is actually going on. We're working on language … to reach some kind of harmony in the issue," Jeff Frost, a lobbyist for several education organizations and school districts involved in K-12 Education Management Group, told Joanna Lin of California Watch.
That language, Frost said, will support the notion that Average Daily Attendance (ADA) can be calculated based on student work.
"Whether they're in the virtual school's learning center or whether they're at home with their mom looking over their shoulder or whether they're in the public library – if they're there working, that's the same as a kid who showed up in school," he added.
Among the principles listed in the group's "Statement of Principles" are "online learning must be held to the same standards as traditional classroom-based education;" "a funding mechanism that is appropriate for online learning should be adopted and equal access must be provided for all of California's six million students;" and "school districts should have flexibility in how online programs are implemented."


Monday, December 5, 2011

Michigan


This week, Michigan legislators my take the long-awaited steps to lifting caps on the number of cyber schools in the state.
SB 619, the cyber school bill, is part of an education reform package making its way through the Michigan legislature. A bill that would lift the cap on creation of charter schools was approved by the Michigan House the week of Nov. 28.
The charter school and the cyber school measures are parent of the "Parental Empowerment  Package." Other measures include a  bill that would would allow public schools to be converted to charter schools. That bill  has been introduced in the Michigan Senate, but hasn't been brought to a full vote. Another bill that would change the criteria for state education aid for  "instruction of nonpublic students by public schools" has been approved by the state Senate, but not by the House.
All the bills in the package must be approved in order for any of the measures to become law.
There are currently two cyber schools in Michigan serving approximately 400 students.
Proponents of SB 619 say more cyber schools will provide more choices to Michigan parents looking for the best educational opportunities for their children.
"Cyber schools are another option we have in reforming our education system in Michigan so that we are meeting the varied needs of all of our students,” said State. Sen. Patrick Colbeck, a sponsor of the bill. “These schools provide a free, public education to students that can be tailored to address each child’s strengths and weaknesses while providing increased one-on-one communication with a teacher.”
Opponents want to wait for more information on the effectiveness of the state's two cyber schools. At an earlier hearing on the measure, State Sen. Hoon-Yung Hopgood wondered why there wasn’t even a baseline report for legislators to key on before a vote is taken on SB 619.
“In fact, we are not even looking at the reports that we demand for these cyber schools at their outset," Hopgood said. "The reason we know that we haven’t looked at these reports is because they are not due yet, and they are not available. Why aren’t we using the best information that we can? Why aren’t we being more transparent? Why aren’t we making sure that there are proper and thorough audits done so we know where the money is going?”


Wednesday, November 30, 2011

New Jersey


Will New Jersey get a virtual charter school in 2012?
Teaneck school officials say that unless the state's  "antiquated" school laws are changed--laws that do not addressed how virtual schools are funded--a K-12 virtual charter school that would be open to students from throughout the state should not be allowed to open in its district.
On the other side, officials of the Garden State Virtual Charter School said they would delay opening if the state charter school law isn't changed to clarify how virtual charter schools are funded.
At the center of the dispute is a New Jersey Education Department letter sent to Teaneck school officials that stated it could be responsible for about $15.4 million in order to fund the virtual charter school.
Teaneck school officials countered  that setting aside such a large amount of money could lead to massive layoffs and cuts to traditional school programs.
After the district's response, New Jersey state education officials clarified their position. They stated that the Teaneck district would not be expected to pay for all the students enrolled at the charter school, only the ones from Teaneck.
In New Jersey, charter schools receive taxpayer dollars for each student equal to 90%  of per-pupil funding in the district where the student resides.
The Garden State Virtual Charter School wants to open next fall with 1,000 students from throughout New Jersey, with enrollment increasing to 3,500 students by its fourth year in operation.
Charter school co-founder, Jason Flynn, the parent of a Teaneck public school student, vowed that the program won’t launch unless the state addresses funding for virtual charter schools. He told NewJersey.com that  he agrees that the Teaneck school district should not be burdened with funding all of the virtual charter school’s students.
“We would only proceed if the funding follows the backpack,” he said. “We’re not here to hurt any students.”
At a recent Teaneck school board meeting, opponents of the charter school said the district is witnessing the "fiscal starvation of the public school system in New Jersey, and ... (the) erosion of local control.”
According to NewJersey.com, some people attending the board meeting  suggested it was time to “Occupy Trenton” and make sure the law is changed.
Charter school co-founder Flynn told NewJersey.com his school and virtual charter school proponents plans to hold a public forum in December month to answer questions  dispel myths and rumors about the school.
The state will decide in January whether to approve Garden State’s application.

Monday, November 21, 2011

Virginia



A report issued by Virginia's Thomas Jefferson Institute for Public Policy is causing a dust up in the state.
The report, "Students Without Borders: Funding Online Education in Virginia," calls for a total restructuring of the state's K-12 funding practices.
"The current educational funding model in Virginia isn't designed for students that can reside in one county but be educated in a school hundreds of miles away.  The current structure assumes that a student living in one school division is educated in that district.  In short, education funding tends to stop at each school division’s border – and that’s not a good system for educating 'students without borders,' " according the report issued by the nonpartisan research group.
In 2010, Virginia established a plan for funding of full-time, multi-district virtual schools. But in 2011, a Virginia senate budget amendment attempted to revise the funding formula, reducing available state funding for educating a student to as little as $2,000, based on the student’s residence.
Virginia Education Association lobbyist Rob Jones told Fredericksburg.com that the situation created  "an opportunity for the for-profit providers to game the system."
According to Fredericksburg.com, Jones wrote that this equates to a "perverse incentive for Virtual School vendors, like K-12 Inc., to locate Virtual Schools in poor school divisions to maximize state funding and corporate profits."
The Jefferson Institute report agreed. "The amendment would have set up dramatic inequities.  Rural school divisions would find it difficult to compete because they would not get enough funding from students in wealthier school divisions.  Meanwhile, stronger, better-funded areas like Fairfax County would be favored and ultimately would dominate the state’s online programs," the report stated.
The budget amendment was successfully vetoed by Virginia Gov. Bob McDonnell, but the Jefferson Institute researchers believe that a similar amendment may be introduced in the future.
Instead, the researchers suggest "changing the paradigm for virtual school students."
Virtual school students should be treated as " 'students without borders” rather than students
from a particular school division.  Funding virtual school students with dollars that equal the
average state-wide share  . . . funding puts all school divisions on a level playing field and
eliminates picking “winners and losers” among school divisions," according to the report.

Thursday, November 17, 2011

California


After the Nov. 16 vote by the Santa Clara County School Board, it is safe to say that Rocketship Education is on a roll. A hard-fought roll, but certainly a roll.
The Santa Clara County board gave Rocketship Ed the go-ahead to launch five K-5 charter schools in San Jose. Rocketship, the much vaunted hybrid-learning charter school network, already has two  K-5 schools in San Jose.
The board's approval, according to the San Jose Mercury News, may also signal an easier road for Rocketship when it goes before the board in December to get approval to open 20 more schools in the county that is the heart of Silicon Valley.
This has been a year of highs and lows for Rocketship's expansion plans. Earlier this month, Milwaukee's Common Council approved a plan for Rocketship to open a city-sponsored elementary school in the Wisconsin city in 2013.
Earlier in the year, Acting Washington, D.C. Schools Chancellor Kaya Henderson indicated that she and others in the District would like to see Rocketship Ed launch at least eight schools in the Nation's Capital.
On the other side of the ledger, a  Rocketship Ed charter school proposal was turned down by the school board that administers schools in East Palo Alto, a low-income, heavily minority community minutes away from Rocketship's Palo Alto headquarters.
Getting approval from the Santa Clara County trustees was no slam dunk. Several superintendents school districts in the county sent board members a 10-page letter that came close to threatening to sue the board if it approved Rocketship Ed's charter application.
"It’s peculiar that no such letter was written before or after we approved the original five Rocketship Countywide Charters in 2009. In fact, there was hardly a whimper from the traditional educational community about the SCCOE Board’s approval of five countywide Rocketships, board chair Jospeh DiSalvo wrote on his blog.
The Mercury News Editorial Board also found the change in attitude by the superintendents, and county staff, peculiar.
"Nothing has changed since the board authorized these charters two years ago, and it reauthorized a nearly identical charter just months ago. This should be an easy decision to benefit struggling students," the editorial stated.



Wednesday, November 9, 2011

Wisconsin


Now, Wisconsin parents who want to enroll their kids in virtual charter schools can breathe a sigh of relief.
OK, they can exhale if Gov. Scott Walker signs SB 2 into law, and it is very likely that he will.
For years, virtual education proponents complained about Wisconsin's 5,250 cap on enrollment in virtual schools. According to Julie Thompson of the Wisconsin Coalition of Virtual School Families, the number of students seeking virtual education opportunities was far greater than the number of slots available.
Waiting lists were long, she added, and the time period to get obtain any opening was short. In 2009, for example, 1,756 students were placed on a waiting list, but 253 spots were offered within the last nine days of school open enrollment, according to the parents' group. Thompson says families had little time to act.
Well, the parents are halfway to getting their wish.
In June, Gov. Walker signed legislation lifting the enrollment cap on virtual schools.
The other half of the wish will come true if  and when SB 2 is signed into law. The bill  expands Wisconsin's open enrollment period for the next school year to three full months in February, March and April.
"SB2 gives families more freedom to choose the best learning environment for their child," Melissa Horn, Wisconsin Virtual Learning Executive Director said. "With this bill, students will no longer have to wait to get the education they deserve, in the environment that works best for them."
The state's largest teachers union, the Wisconsin Education Association,  did not oppose expanding the enrollment period or dropping the enrollment cap – as long as the state looks at quality issues for those schools, and re-visits the funding of virtual schools as part of the open enrollment program.

Monday, October 31, 2011

Michigan

Hours after the Michigan Senate approved a bill that would end caps on the number of virtual charter schools and lift restrictions on enrollment in the cyber charters, opponents of the measure launched a full-court press aimed at stopping the legislation.
The Michigan Education Association (MEA)  asked its members to urge their legislators to vote no on SB 619, the measure that would lift the restrictions. The Michigan Association of School Administrators, issued a statement that the proposal does not offer any guarantee of school quality. Superintendents of local school districts took to the hustings campaigning against the measure.
"I think more research has to be done to find out just how effective [online charter schools] are instead of just suddenly passing legislation -- at least at the Senate side -- in order to require unlimited access to this," Rockford Public Schools Superintendent Mike Shibler told WOOD-TV.
"Students certainly can benefit from cyber education or learning online, whether it be credit recovery or whether it be courses that are difficult to get otherwise from their local high school," the Rockford superintendent said. "But they also, I think, can benefit ... from actual 1-on-30, 1-on-25" relationships with teachers.
Opponents, including the MEA, contend that the cyber charters would be run by "private companies and would use public taxpayer dollars for funding. While this may be the legislature’s answer to 'education reform,' a report by University of Colorado education professors Gene V. Glass and Kevin G. Weiner criticizes the move because there is no high-quality evidence of their effectiveness," according to the MEA.
Oakland Schools Superintendent Vickie L. Markavitch encouraged parents to lobby their legislators not to support the sweeping reforms in a podcast posted on the Oakland Schools website earlier this month.
In the 12-minute video, Markavitch warned of unintended consequences that can’t be foreseen without proper research.
“Reform means change, and although no one ever intends to make things worse, the wrong reform and the wrong change can do just that,” she said. “There’s little evidence that those proposing reforms have even studied the research.”
But State Sen. Patrick Colbeck, a proponent of SB 619, said demand is driving the need to expand cyber charter school options. He said the two existing year-old cyber charter schools—where students in grades K-12 take all of their coursework online—have thousands of students on their waiting lists.
"I think it's going to be a game-changer for Michigan and our kids," said State Sen. Patrick Colbeck, who sponsored the cyber charter bill.
State Sen. Hoon-Yung Hopgood spoke for many of the opponents when he said the legislature is moving too fast. He said the current restrictions were put in place with the intent that they be lifted if, after two years, the schools demonstrated success. The schools opened in 2010, meaning the two-year mark won't be reached until this summer.
"It's really disappointing that we're just going to blow the caps off these schools when we don't have all the information on them," Hopgood said.
The cyber charter measure is part of an education reform package that would provide expanded opportunities for private school students to take public school classes; for public schools to provide programs for private schools, and for public and private students to enroll in both high school and community college at the same time.
The bills, part of a nine-bill package, now moves on to the House for consideration.

Friday, October 28, 2011

Virginia

The Virginia Association of School Superintendents have a plan for reformulating the state's goals for K-12 education and virtual education plays a significant role in the outline.
The plan, approved by the state's 133 superintendents, wants to see students become prepared for college and other post secondary education, and for careers.
The No.1 objective in the "Instructional Delivery" section of the plan is to online learning courses available to all Virginia students. To do this, according to the report, Virginia needs to "provide funding to support virtual programs in the form of materials, hardware, software, space, and personnel to school divisions in order that all schools, regardless of size, can offer instructional alternatives to students."
The plan also wants the state to take a new look at seat-time requirements.
A proponent of the plan, Gloucester County Superintendent Howard B. "Ben" Kiser said the evolution of technology and virtual learning caused the superintendents to rethink time in education, according to the Richmond Times Dispatch.
"We know through virtual curriculum … students do not have to sit in a class for 140 hours (and) 180 school days," he told the Times Dispatch.
The Virginia Education Association did not immediately take a position on the plan. Earlier this month, the teachers union urged Gov. Bob McDOnnell to make K-12 education a funding priority.

Monday, October 17, 2011

Michigan

Three members of the Michigan Board of Education asked lawmakers to vote against proposals that would lift caps on the number of virtual charter schools in the state.
The three members – Marianne McGuire, Kathleen Straus, and Casandra Ulbrich – took an unusual step of issuing a statement after opposing a proposed open letter about the reforms at the October state school board meeting. The trio also said they were also against creating a "parent trigger" that would allow conversion of public schools into charters.
This is the latest volley in a pitched battle over education reform.
Earlier this month, the Michigan state senate approved a measure that allows the expansion of charter and cyber charter schools.The bill removes a cap on the number of schools authorized by state universities and also makes it easier for successful out-of-state charter school operators to supervise school in Michigan.
The bill has been sent to the Michigan House and is part of a seven-bill package that aims to increase choice for public school students and their parents.
Proponents say Michigan parents need choices so children can escape failing schools and that greater choice greater will foster more competition which will forces all schools to improve.
Opponents, ranging from the Michigan Education Association to legislative Democrats, argue the measures help charter schools while stripping traditional public schools of necessary funding.
"All we're doing is subsidizing these for-profit ventures and diverting scarce resources from our neighborhood, locally governed public schools," Democratic state Sen. Hoon-Yung Hopgood told the Associated Press.
The three board of education members said they wanted to retain the cap on cyber charters because there isn't enough data to show if these types of schools are effective.
Instead of the proposed reforms, the three board members said the way to improve Michigan's public schools included improving access to early childhood programs, reducing class sizes, and removing incentives to reduce the number of school days.

Tuesday, October 4, 2011

Tennessee

When the Tennessee legislature approved the Public Virtual School Act earlier this year, and when Gov. Bill Haslam signed it into law, did these lawmakers put the cart before the horse?
That's what the state board of education will try to determine later this month when it meets to establish rules and guidelines for virtual schools.
That's right, Tennessee has a new virtual school law that went into effect on July 1. It even has a new K-8 virtual school, the Tennessee Virtual Academy (TNVA) that opened its doors this fall. But the state doesn't have any rules or guidelines that governing the operation of virtual schools.
That may all change in the next few weeks, and there will be a fight over the rules.
Proponents of the Public Virtual School Act say the new law will help move Tennessee to the forefront of the education reform movement. They add that bumps are to be expected with the introduction of anything new.
Bumps there were when TNVA opened its doors this fall. There were enrollment glitches, problems getting students the hardware and software they needed for classes, and a lot of bruised feelings when traditional school districts lost students to the tiny Union County Public Schools, which contracted with K12 Inc. for online school services.
"We believe the Tennessee Virtual Academy will be an excellent choice for children who need personalized learning programs," said Wayne Goforth, director of schools for Union County Public Schools. "Our school district is focused on providing the best education we can to all of our students. This online school is another opportunity for us to be innovative and responsive to the education needs of every child."
Opponents aren't so sure. Critics say K12 Inc., through lobbyists, pushed a virtual-school bill through to passage in the closing minutes of the state legislature. They say money precious school funding is flowing out of Tennessee and into Virginia, where K12 Inc. is based.
"I don’t think the state is looking out for the child’s best interest," Dickson County school board member Steve Haley said. "I think they are looking at private companies’ interest." Dickson lost 24 students to TNVA. Since the Public Virtual School Act allows state funds to follow students, Dickson County schools lost nearly $81,000 – or roughly $4,300 per student – to K12 and Union County.
According to the Nashville Tennessean, Gov. Haslam, said recently that he's just now learning its full impact.
"I'm growing increasingly familiar with it. It's something I want to understand the ramifications a lot better. I understand how (virtual education) could be very beneficial; you could offer subjects that aren't offered other places. But I do think we have to think through the consequences a little bit more than we've done so far."
That's what the Tennessee Board of Education will try to do in October.

Tuesday, September 27, 2011

Michigan

A Michigan GOP Education Reform plan that includes expansion of online learning opportunities, is attracting a lot of attention.
StudentsFirst, the lobbying group headed by former Washington, D.C. schools chief Michelle Rhee, has given nearly $1 million to the effort that would change teacher tenure in the state and mandate a school choice program.
Opponents of the plan, such as the Michigan Education Association plans to spend more than $300,000 against the reform package. This is 11% more than the organization spent in 2010. Most of the money, according to the MEA website, will go for radio and TV ads.
"Many of the concepts introduced in these bills were first mentioned by Gov. Snyder in his education message this spring. But it's apparent that the attacks on public education continue. None of these bills are meant to improve education. This is more of the same push to destroy public education: schools run by private entities, back-door vouchers, policies based on rhetoric rather than research, and more state mandates -- despite the Republican cut of $1 billion from public schools earlier this year," according to an MEA statement.
Proponents of the reform plan say that changes such as eliminating caps on the number of charter and online schools is long overdue.
"The Parent Empowerment Education Reform package is about freeing parents to pursue the opportunities that work best for their children and giving schools the freedom they need to innovate and excel," State Sen. Phil Pavlov, chair of the Senate Education Committee wrote on his website.

Monday, September 19, 2011

Florida


The Florida Board of Education is meeting this week and it has the Florida Virtual School (FLVS) on its mind.
At these meetings, the board plans to set its priorities for the upcoming year. On the agenda is a plan give FLVS, the nation's largest state-led virtual school,  the " authority and responsibility of a school district. FLVS students would be allowed to participate in extracurricular activities in traditional school districts.
Other board ideas for FLVS include:

  • Authorizes the State Board of Education (SBE)to oversee the performance of Florida Virtual School board of trustees in enforcement of all laws and rules. 
  • Authorizes SBE to offer an alternative readiness screening for kindergarten students enrolled in a full time virtual education program. 
  •  Requires Florida Virtual School to fulfill obligations of exceptional education students. 
  •  Clarifies districts eligible for the sparsity supplement before the wealth adjustment calculation will only be required to provide one virtual option.

Sunday, September 11, 2011

Idaho


At long last, there is clarity about Idaho's plans to require students to take online classes as a high school graduation requirement.
Well, at least there is clarity for the moment.
Last week, the Idaho Board of Education voted to require that beginning with the class of 2016, students must take at least two online classes in order to graduate from high school. One of those classes must be taken virtually, without a classroom teacher present. Of course, there can be a virtual teach supervising instruction.
The board voted 8-0 to approve the plan.
The legislation that was approved and signed into law instead directed the state Board of Education to draft standards governing the online course requirements. The board directed a subcommittee to decide how trustees would proceed in April and that panel mostly discussed making one or two online credits a requirement to graduate high school.
Most of the opposition was directed at the education changes as a whole not just the online requirements, board spokesman Mark Browning said.
For example, Scott Rogers, superintendent of the Minidoka County School District, said there are a lot of unanswered questions about the state’s proposal.
“Schools have been ramping up for these changes,” Rogers told the Magic Valley Times-News. “We have yet to see all the details.”
Melissa McGrath, spokeswoman for the Idaho State Department of Education, said online class initiatives should be cost-neutral or generate savings for most school districts.
“It’s just changing the learning environment,” she said. “A teacher will be somewhere else.”
It will be up to each school district to set up a format to offer online classes.
If districts contract with a private vendor, districts will receive all the state funding and then pay the vendor. Districts could also choose to allow students to take classes through the state-sponsored Idaho Digital Learning Academy.
Idaho schools chief Luna, who sits on the board, lauded trustees for their work on the rule.
Speaking for proponents of the online requirements, Luna told LocalNews8.com:  "I think that this proposal before us goes a long ways toward our responsibility as a board and as a state to assure that our students have the ability and the necessary skills that they will need when they graduate from high school."
The board will now hold a 21-day comment period on the rule, though board spokesman Browning said trustees are unlikely to reverse their decision. The rule will go before state lawmakers during the 2012 session, which starts in January.
That said, many school districts are already moving in the direction of expanding online class opportunities.
“We recognize that students in today’s world need to be able to navigate the online realm for education,” Minidoka County School Superintendent Rogers said.

Wednesday, September 7, 2011

Idaho

Decision Day may well be Sept. 10.That's the day the Idaho Board of Education is scheduled to vote on a proposal that would require students to take at least two online courses in order to graduate from high school.
Getting to this point hasn't been easy.
After one of the nation's bitterest fights over technology-centered education reforms, the Idaho legislature approved a package of laws called "Students Come First."
One of the proposals Idaho Superintendent of Instruction Tom Luna believed to be central to the reform package was to require students to take at least four online classes in order to graduate from high school. However, to get the package approved by the legislature, that part of the reform plan had to be removed.
in order to get legislative approval for the After Otter signed all three measures a new fight broke out. Luna announced he would go around the state legislature and ask the Idaho Board of Education to approve the online class graduation requirements.
The Idaho Technology Task Force was created. Its 39 members crisscrossed the state this summer holding hearings on how technology should be used in the classroom. In August, a task force panel recommended that Idaho require two online classes become part of the state's high school graduation requirement. The proposal states that one of the two required online classes must be taught remotely, without a teacher present in the classroom.
Idaho teacher Sue Darden spoke for many of the plan's opponents at one of the summer hearings.
"What I'm opposed to is removing the teacher from the equation. What kind of instruction are they going to be getting? What kind of interaction are they going to have?" asked Darden, a 21-year teaching veteran who works in the Meridian School District.
Idaho Education Association President Penni Cyr, added that the organization doesn't want the proposal to require one of the online courses to be “asynchronous,” which means the teacher would not be in the classroom with the student, although a proctor or other employee without a teaching certificate might be.
“What is the plan for assuring that students who need additional help have timely access to a certified teacher with content expertise?” Cyr asked.
Proponents say that the new state education reform laws mandate that there be some kind of online course required for graduation.
Doing nothing is not an option. Additionally, online courses will better prepare Idaho students for college and careers, where online learning is already commonplace.
"Virtual education offers limitless options for kids," says parent Rebecca Bohman, whose children take online course from home through Bonneville School District 93's Virtual Academy.
Adds District 93 representative Guy Bliesner says online learning offers the same, if not better, education than traditional classrooms.
"Our teachers are available here, they can do tutoring sessions and if you have a child struggling with the online approach, you can meet with them and address the problem," says Bliesner.
In addition to the online course requirements, Idaho is introducing teacher merit pay and shifting money from salaries toward classroom technology, phasing in laptops for teachers and students.
The changes were so controversial that opponents launched a successful referendum campaign earlier this year to repeal them. The referendum will go before Idaho voters in November 2012.
As soon as the Sept. 10 vote is final, Liberating Learning will broadcast the results and post an in-depth story in Battleground.

Tuesday, August 30, 2011

Pennsylvania

And so it begins again. Debate over cyber charter and traditional charter schools in Pennsylvania has returned to the spotlight.
Returning to center stage are two bills, SB 904 and HB 1348. The companion bills would streamline legal procedures to launch a charter school, lift all enrollment caps and creates an appeal procedure if a local school board rejects a viable charter school application.
Earlier this year, Pennsylvania Auditor General Jack Wagner called for a moratorium on the creation of new cyber charter and charter schools until a new funding system can be put into place.
School districts in Pennsylvania agreed with Wagner. Pennsylvania has 159 charter schools and 13 cyber charter schools with more than
90,000 students enrolled. They receive funding from local public school districts. The districts say current funding system, which for cyber charter students, called for them to send district-generate funds as well as state money to online course providers. This is one reason this year school districts from the Poconos to State College, Penn., have launched their own virtual schools. These districts want to keep their students, and the money, in the local district.
Opponents of the measures say the bills will reduce accountability for charter schools.
In a blog post, The Education Law Center of Pennsylvania, a legal advocacy group, said it "believes that important reforms are needed for Pennsylvania’s system of charter and cyber charter schools. Unfortunately, Senate Bill 904 and similar legislation introduced in
the House of Representatives do not include the reforms truly needed to strengthen the charter school system. Instead, these bills include changes that would greatly expand the number and size of charter schools, would replace the role of local school districts in
approving and monitoring charter schools with a new state agency in Harrisburg, and would water down the accountability system for charter schools. This is the wrong approach," according to the law center.
After he testified before a legislative committee, the executive director of the Pennsylvania School Board Association made a video in which he remained non-committal about the legislation, but added he wished it contained funding reform.
Proponents, however, see the legislation as long over due and very much needed.
"It is clear to me that we are at a pivotal time in Pennsylvania’s education reform movement. The early success of charter schools can either be a firm foundation upon which a new child centered system of public education will be built, or another attempt at reform that
was bastardized and destroyed by our inability to break away from the status quo," Lawrence Jones, president of the Pennsylvania Coalition for Public Charter Schools, told a Pennsylvania education legislative committee.

Tuesday, August 9, 2011

Michigan

New rules issued by the Michigan Department of Education will expand online learning opportunities for students throughout the state.
Everyone isn't happy.
Before the new regulations were issued, Michigan law limited students to two online classes a semester. School district and virtual charter school that allowed students to take more than two online classes operated under special waivers from the Michigan Department
of Education.
The new rules, issued in July, make it easier for school districts to get waivers to the state law. This means, for example, the state's 57 middle school districts can create virtual charter schools for up to 10% of students who reside in the district's boundaries. What's more, middle school students would be able to take all or most of their classes online. Prior to the rule change,
these student could only take two courses per semester.
The education department also issued new rules that streamline the process for approval of seat-time waivers.
The impact of the new rules was felt quickly. The Michigan Department of Education reported it has received a half-dozen applications from districts since the guidelines were issued last month. More applications are in the pipeline, state officials said.
The new guidelines are in response to Gov. Rick Snyder's push for the Legislature to remove rules that cap some online enrollment.
Although the MDE has the power to give districts flexibility, the Legislature would need to act to completely remove restrictions. "We
agree with the governor that this is a good thing for students," Barbara Fardell, a manager in the state Office of Educational Improvement and Innovation, told the Detroit News.
Proponents of the new rules allowing for the expansion of online learning opportunities are heartened by the moves of the education department.
"We want educators to have the flexibility to reach every student as we reinvent our education system that will allow students to learn any time, any place, any way, and at any pace," said State Superintendent of Schools Mike Flanagan.
Michael Van Beek, director of education policy at the Mackinac Center for Public Policy, added that it is time that Michigan should be like other states that have more open access to online education.
Opponents of the rule change urged state education officials move slower and add safeguards to any growth of online learning.
The Michigan Education Association, the state's largest teacher's union, provided guidance to its members on virtual education issues.
In a 2009, union-endorsed report called "The Realities of K-12 Virtual Education," the authors wrote, " the rapid growth of this new form of schooling raises questions of cost, funding, and variable quality that require the immediate attention of policymakers."
The report recommends that before policy changes that allow for more online learning options, policy makers:
-- Adopt new regulations governing the provision of online K-12 schooling.
-- Call for audits of providers of virtual education.
-- Recognize legitimate accrediting agencies.
-- Require credible assessment and evaluation.

Friday, July 29, 2011

Oklahoma

Here's hoping a recent Oklahoma state Education Board decision ends the confusion that has caused confusion and stymied fall enrollment in virtual schools.
Antiquated transfer laws were being enforced in a way that stopped many parents from transferring their children out of traditional public schools and into virtual classes. On July 28, The state ed board revoked those regulations and instead instructed school districts to follow state law. Those regulations say that Open transfers cannot be denied for any reason if the receiving district accepts the student.
Another problem cropped up when the state ed board warned the state's first virtual charter, Epic One on One Charter School, to stop enrolling pre-kindergarten students in Oklahoma City and Norman and to halt enrolling pre-K through 5 students in Tulsa.
The reason: state law requires that a charter school be physically located in the district that grants the charter. Epic One is chartered through Graham Public Schools, near Ardmore.
In reviewing the solicitation posted on the Epic One on One website, the state board of ed told Epic One, "it is evident that the intention is to provide a physical location for students within a school for a full school day. Pursuant to the law, you must close the remote sites immediately."
David Chaney, Epic's founder, told The Oklahoman that the facilities are not schools - but are centers where students can access the curriculum on computers and Internet provided by Epic. However, descriptions of the three sites on Epic One's web page have been changed. There is also with a statement explaining the situation.
Chaney said about 1,200 students have enrolled in the virtual school so far, and about 100 of them have indicated they would prefer a physical location to attend.
"While we work to resolve this issue, we want to make everyone aware that this applies only to the students that were planning to physically attend our resource centers, which includes approximately 100 enrollments," Chaney wrote. "These developments do not affect our charter and will not prohibit Epic from starting in the fall.
"All of our students are virtual students," Chaney said. "It's no different from our other model. It's a self-paced model, and anytime the facility is open, parents can drop them off or pick them up, and
while they are there they will get to have access to their Internet and curriculum."
Epic One has battled to launch as a virtual charter school. Plans for the virtual charter school devolved into a fight in 2010 when Epic One found itself without a sponsor and with no access to state funding. A court ruling that the virtual charter should receive state money came too late for the school to open in the fall of 2010. In early 2011, the Okfuskee County School District said it would sponsor the virtual charter school. Calvert Education services said it would provide curriculum and supervision for the charter. With that, Epic One started working to open for statewide enrollment in the fall 2011.

Thursday, July 21, 2011

Pennsylvania

What started as a trickle, a few Pennsylvania school districts launching their own cyber schools as a way to reduce expenditures and to lure students to the districts, has turned into a deluge.
It is safe to say that when K-12 classes open this fall, more Pennsylvania school districts that ever before will offer virtual education options.
From the Connellsville Area District, which is southeast of Monongahela, to the Mars Area District, which is north of McKeesport, to the Phoenville Area District, near Pottstown.
The Waynesboro Area School Board was told recently that if it created a cyber school in conjunction with the Franklin Virtual Academy, instead of sending $8,000 to $15,000 per student per year to cyber charter schools in the state, it would approximately $2,775 per
student per semester to offer FVA online classes. What's more, the students would still be part of the Waynesboro district.
Money is at the heart of this district-base cyber school movement.
In Pennsylvania, districts must pay the tuition for students within their borders who attend charter and cyber charter schools elsewhere, opening a cyber school to retain students or lure them back is in the districts' financial interest. For each child enrolled in a cyber charter school, the district receives just 20% of the state funding it would receive for a student
attending a traditional public school.
"By setting up their own cyber schools, districts are actually able to save money," Steve Robinson, a spokesman for the Pennsylvania School Boards Association, recently told a McClatchy Tribune reporter.
In June, Rep. James Roebuck, the Democratic chairman of the Pennsylvania House Education Committee, introduced a bill that would shift the cost of underwriting charter and cyber charter students away from the districts to the state.Roebuck told a McClatchy-Tribune reporter that his bill would the measure, which would require the state to pay tuition for
Pennsylvania's 50,000 charter and cyber charter students, could save districts $187 million.
But changes in the state's funding structure can't happen soon enough for Pennsylvania's school districts, which are looking at record state loses in state educational funding for the 2011-2012 school year.
The local school district know that their state funding problems won't attract parents who are looking for alternatives to traditional public schools. So, the school are turning to marketing tools such as TV commercials.
Ads touting the new district-sponsored virtual schools are being underwritten by the Central Pennsylvania Public School Coalition and the Pennsylvania Association for Rural and Small Schools, the ads are slated to start airing before the start of the school year.
Nick Trombetta, the CEO of the Pennsylvania Cyber Charter School told the Altoona Mirror that he welcomed the competition, but that often districts may not be capable of matching the promises made in the advertisements.
School officials are also pitching other reasons for cyber students to take their online classes through a traditional school district.
Students "will be able to participate in all extracurricular activities. They will receive a Connellsville Area School District diploma. Our diploma is considered a Tier 1. A cyber charter school diploma is Tier 2. A Tier 2 diploma can cause problems when people
try to enlist in the military or to advance in the military," Tammy Stern, acting superintendent of the Connellsville district, told the Connellsville Daily Courier.

Tuesday, July 12, 2011

Georgia

Attention certainly must be paid to the cheating scandal in Atlanta Public Schools. But a committee of the Georgia lawmakers have launched a study that may have a greater impact on the future of education--especially virtual education--in Atlanta and the state Georgia.
What the lawmakers want to do is change Georgia's "Quality Basic Education Act," the law that governs state funding to public schools
According to the Atlanta Journal-Constitution, "The committee will look at revamping or replacing the QBE formula, which officials say has not really been adjusted through the years to take into account schools' increasing need for technology or issues such as the rising costs of textbooks."
This is welcomed news to group supporting online education such as the Georgia Families for Public Virtual Education. In a post, the group points out that "Prior to being struck down by the Supreme Court, the Georgia Charter Schools Commission and the General Assembly approved a $5,800 per student funding
allotment (for students attending virtual schools). Under State Board of Education approval, per student funding will be significantly
less."
Getting equal funding has been a hard-fought battle for supporters of virtual education in Georgia.
In 2010, two virtual schools decided not to open because per pupil funding from the state was not adequate to support a quality educational program. After reconsidering its decision, the Georgia Charter School Commission changed its mind and approved $5,800 per student. This was still less than the $6,000-$7,000 sought by virtual school supporters, but enough so the virtual school operators believed they could open in fall 2011.
Then the Georgia Supreme Court court struck down a law empowering the Georgia Charter Commission to approve and finance charter schools.
Although all Georgia virtual schools have either been re-approved by the state board of education, or have become part of a traditional school district, the reduction in state funding could jeopardizes the future of these schools.
Few opponents to revising the how the state spends its education dollars were at the first meeting of the education finance committee. However, according to Atlanta Journal-Constitution blogger Maureen Downey, Georgia House budget staff director John Brown, who is about to leave the legislature after 25 years, was quite candidate on the reasons for the funding problems.
"Brown blamed the failures of the other funding review committees on two factors: Governors who wanted only recommendations that were 'revenue neutral,' and overly ambitious committee recommendations that were more 'wish lists,' " Downey wrote.
"We are not going to come up with a formula that reaches for excellence. We are not putting an orchestra in every school. We are not going to be up there. We are going to create a formula so that every school system has enough money to get the basic job done,'" Brown said.

Thursday, July 7, 2011

Minnesota

The public showdown between BlueSky Online School, a Minnesota-based virtual charter school, and the Minnesota Department of Education is on hold.
First, what was supposed to be Blue Sky's day in court went behind-closed-doors for negotiation sessions. The hoped for result was a settlement of a bitter argument between the state's education department and the West St. Paul virtual charter school that serves about 500 students in grades 7-12, who live throughout the state.
Next, those talks were placed in limbo when the Minnesota state government shutdown during an impasse over the state budget.
It's too bad because, according to the St. Paul Pioneer Press, it looked as if a white knight was about to ride to BlueSky's rescue. According to the paper, the 4,400-student West St. Paul-Mendota Heights-Eagan district hopes to team up with BlueSky to launch an online program this fall. The district would then absorb the online charter in 2012.
Minnesota's Department of Education approved the proposal late last month, the same week it asked a judge to delay a hearing over the school's forced closure, according to the Pioneer Press
Now, everything is on hold until the state budget is finalized. That, some believe, won't happen any time soon.
BlueSky Online School and the Minnesota Department of Education have been battling for several years and the charter school has been under intense state scrutiny over allegations that it has issued diplomas to students who fell short of state graduation requirements.
In 2010, while looking into graduation rates of all Minnesota online schools that receive state money, the education department improperly released private data, which included academic transcripts of 20 BlueSky students who allegedly did not meet graduation requirements.
The student data, according to state education officials, were given to an "unauthorized individual" on Nov. 2, 2010. It was a coincidence, they added, that this was the same day a department news release threatened "crippling fines" against the school if BlueSky officials could not prove they were following state law.
Blue Sky’s administrators concede there have been problems, but say they have worked hard to address everything that’s been brought to their attention. But, they added, every time they change polices to meet new state standards, the standards were changed.
Finally, in spring 2011, state officials said despite two years of warnings BlueSky Online School kept issuing diplomas to unqualified students. The state was ready to take action to shut down the online school.
That's where everything stood at the end of June when the two sides were to meet in St. Paul for a two-day hearing to decide BlueSky's future.
Who's right? "Who knows," wrote MinnPost blogger Beth Hawkins.
"Your Humble Blogger had been looking forward to the hearing, to be conducted by the state Office of Administrative Hearings. There, both sides were to lay out their answers in plain English to an administrative law judge who, as a neutral finder of fact, would at long last create an official record," she wrote.
BlueSky's future won't be decided until the state's budget crisis is solved.

Friday, July 1, 2011

Tennessee

The "Virtual Public Schools Act" became law in Tennessee on July 1.

The law, which was known as HB 1030, allows for the creation of virtual charter schools.

The law also allows for-profit companies to operate virtual schools in Tennessee. For-profit operators must have a Local Education Agency (LEA) sponsor. The law also mandates that virtual school operators "provide instructional materials, access to a computer and printer, and an Internet connection."

Virtual school operators must also maintain an administrative office in Tennessee.

Opponents to the new law say that money will be siphoned away from traditional public schools which are struggling to make ends meet.

The Virtual Public Schools Act was part of a series of education reform bill passed in Tennessee this year. Laws lifting enrollment caps on charter schools and allowing for creation of more charter schools also became law on July 1.

Wednesday, June 22, 2011

Oregon

It passed. HB2301, which will loosen restrictions on enrollment in Oregon virtual schools, was approved.
Victory was literally snatched out of the jaws of defeat.
Here's what happened.
On June 20, the Oregon House effectively defeated the measure when the bill received a 30-30 vote.
After the vote, the Republican caucus left the House floor for a long closed-door meeting. Afterward, GOP House Leader Kevin Cameron switched his "yes" vote to "no." This meant he was voting on the prevailing side, and according to Oregon House rules, this means
he has the right to serve notice of reconsideration of HB2301. Basically, he could ask for another House floor vote on the measure.
This maneuver left House Democrats fuming, according to the Salem Register-Guard, because of a widely quoted agreement between party leaders last week that each of the 14 education bills would be judged on their own merits on the floor.
Cameron had the measure re-introduced and allowed for some amendments. The amendments changed everything.
On June 21, a new version of the bill was approved on a 33-27 vote after the proposal’s sponsors agreed to an amendment that would set up a government task force to closely examine how the state could ensure some quality control at virtual schools, an issue critics had expressed concern about.
The promise of those amendments was enough to persuade three House Democrats to change their votes from “no” to “yes” on the bill.
While efforts to amend the bill were viewed by some as an attempt at compromise, opponents complained about the last-minute nature of the amendments, which they said were not adequately vetted.
“Through a backroom deal done in the dead of night to revive a bill we had defeated, House Republicans have forced through an incomplete and expensive bill that will line the pockets of for-profit charter schools and hurt our children,” House Democratic Leader Dave Hunt of Gladstone told the Register-Guard.
HB 2301 was one of several bills approved by the Oregon House and Senate that should help expand virtual education opportunities in Oregon. Others include HB Bill , 3681 which allows students to more easily enroll in a school district where they don’t reside, and HB 3645, which allows public universities and community colleges to sponsor nearby charter schools.
Opponents of the measures called the bills "bad legislation.
"I'm disappointed that in the rush to get out of Salem, some really bad bills passed that will do real harm to our schools that are already in crisis," said Gail Rasmussen, president of the Oregon Education Association, the state's largest teachers union.
All of these reforms -- and others -- are expected to be signed into law by Gov. John Kitzhaber.
Among the changes, the new laws will:
-- Allow students to in enroll in charters and virtual charters that are outside of the neighborhood school district.
--Lifts enrollment caps on virtual charter schools.
-- Allow students to enroll in virtual charter schools without obtain permission from their school district.
-- Allow up to 5% up of virtual charter schools’ courses taught by teachers who are not licensed in Oregon.
Proponents of virtual schools say there is a downside to the changes. The new laws allows districts to deny local students’ access to a
virtual charter school once 3% of district students have enrolled in a virtual charter schools. But parents will be able to enroll
their children in virtual charter schools based in other district. They can also appeal these denials to the State Board of Education.
Currently, fewer than 1% of Oregon’s schoolchildren attend virtual charter schools.

Tuesday, June 21, 2011

Oregon

It ain't over in the fight to loosen restrictions on virtual school enrollment in Oregon.
At least that's the hoped for impact of a political maneuver by Oregon House Republican Leader Kevin Cameron.
A 30-30 House vote on HB 2301, a measure that would have allowed more flexibility in enrolling in part-time and full-time K-12 classes, meant that the measure was defeated.
After the vote, the Republican caucus left the House floor for a long closed-door meeting. Afterward, Cameron switched his "yes" vote to "no." This meant he was no voting on the prevailing side, and according to Oregon House rules, this meant he had the right to serve
notice of reconsideration of HB2301. Basically, this means there could be another House floor vote on the measure.
This maneuver left House Democrats fuming, according to the Salem Register-Guard, because of a widely quoted agreement between party leaders last week that each of the 14 education bills would be judged on their own merits on the floor.
Supporters of HB 2301 say the measure would give online schools room to grow by allowing more public school students in. Current restrictions make it hard for students to transfer to online schools.
“Parents of children in virtual charter schools in Oregon have spent the last six years with a guillotine blade poised over the neck of the schools that have worked such wonders in their lives,” Rep. Matt Wingard, a Wilsonville Republican who is a consultant for the
state’s largest online school, the Oregon Connections Academy, told the Register-Guard.
Opponents of HB 2301 said they are concerned by the lack of control existing public education boards have over the quality of education at online schools.
Rep. Michael Dembrow, a Portland Democrat, said he believes the bill could allow private companies to make vast profits from public education dollars.
Most online schools are public schools that receive state funding based on the number of students they serve, in the same way bricks-and-mortar public school districts do.
Many of Oregon's school districts and the Oregon Education Association, the state's largest teachers union, opposed the bill.
If approved, the proposed changes would:
-- Allow students to in enroll in charters and virtual charters that are outside of the neighborhood school district.
--Lifts enrollment caps on virtual charter schools.
-- Allow students to enroll in virtual charter schools without obtain permission from their school district.
-- Allow up to 5% up of virtual charter schools’ courses taught by teachers who are not licensed in Oregon.

Monday, June 20, 2011

Oregon

June 20 could be decision time for an Oregon bill that would give virtual schools more freedom.
The Oregon House is set to vote on HB 2301, which would ease enrollment restrictions on part-time and full-time online classes, sometime during the day. If the measure passes the House, it will go to the Oregon Senate where it will most likely stand for a vote sometime the same evening.
The bill is part of a package of education reform measures that could literally change the depth and breadth of educational opportunities for K-12 Oregon students.
One of the bills at the center of the tension, HB 3645, would allow Oregon’s public colleges to sponsor a charter school.
HB 3681, would expand charter schools’ open-enrollment policy to traditional public schools. regular public schools, thus increasing educational options.
HB 3645 will help charter schools be judged more on their merits rather than on the political whims of local schools boards.
All or most of the parts of these bills, including HB 2301, which would loosen enrollment restrictions that currently restrict many families from being able to choose a virtual charter school, are being actively opposed by the Oregon Education Association (OEA), the
state's largest teachers union.
According to the OEA, "Legislators want to trade good policy and education funding for bad policy ideas that don't make sense for students."
Other proposed changes would:
-- Allow students to in enroll in charters and virtual charters that are outside of the neighborhood school district.
--Lifts enrollment caps on virtual charter schools.
-- Allow students to enroll in virtual charter schools without obtain permission from their school district.
-- Allow up to 5% up of virtual charter schools’ courses taught by teachers who are not licensed in Oregon.
To learn the results of the vote on the virtual school measure and the other education reform bills, click here on June 21.

Tuesday, June 14, 2011

Pennsylvania

Another Pennsylvania state legislator stepped into the arena with a plan to reconstruct the way the state funds charter and cyber charter schools.
The new bill arrives at a time when a Stanford University study raises questions about the state's charter schools and when a growing number of Pennsylvania school districts, many claiming they are short-changed by the state when their students attend cyber charter schools, are scrambling to launch their own cyber charters by fall.
Earlier this week, Rep. James Roebuck, the Democratic chairman of the Pennsylvania House Education Committee, introduced a bill that would shift the cost of underwriting charter and cyber charter students away from the districts to the state.
Roebuck told a McClatchy-Tribune reporter that his bill would the measure, which would require the state to pay tuition for Pennsylvania's 50,000 charter and cyber charter students, could save districts $187 million.
This is not the first measure introduced this year to find a new funding solution. Other bills have been introduced only to languish in the Pennsylvania legislature. Lawmakers are feeling heat to do something about the funding situation because late in 2010, state Auditor Gen. Jack Wagner called for a moratorium on creation any new new charter or cyber charters in the state because , the current funding system has serious inequities in how tax money is used to finance these public school alternatives.
In addition to changing the way charter and cyber charter schools are funded, the Roebuck bill would create an Office of Charter and Cyber Charter Schools within the Department of Education, which would oversee these schools. The schools would also be required to meet
academic standards or lose their charters.
The quality of education provided by Pennsylvania's charter and cyber charters was called into question by a study by Stanford University's Center for Research on Education Outcomes (CREDO).
The report, Charter School Performance in Pennsylvania, showed mixed results in math and reading, with all cyber charter students lagging their counterparts in public schools.
"Elementary school students enrolled in charter schools outperformed their peers in traditional public schools in both math and reading, while those enrolled in middle and multilevel charter schools performed worse in both subjects than their peers at traditional public schools," the report says.
A poor showing by the state's online charter schools dragged down the overall charter school numbers.
Students at cyber charters, who accounted for 30% of the charter students covered by the study, performed significantly worse than students at public schools, the study said.
Belief that local school districts can do a better job than the current cyber charters, coupled with a desire to capture more state education money, may be why Pennsylvania school districts from Bensalem to Reading want to start their own cyber charter schools.
Because districts must pay the tuition for students within their borders who attend charter and cyber charter schools elsewhere, opening a cyber school to retain students or lure them back is in the districts' financial interest.
For each child enrolled in a cyber charter school, the district receives just 20% of the state funding it would receive for a student attending a traditional public school.
"By setting up their own cyber schools, districts are actually able to save money," Steve Robinson, a spokesman for the Pennsylvania School Boards Association, told a McClatchy Tribune reporter.

Sunday, June 12, 2011

Idaho

Here's what Digital Learning Now co-founders former Florida Gov. Jeb Bush and former West Virginia Gov. Bob Wise will find in Idaho this week: An all-out fight over the future of virtual education in the state.
There's no doubt about it. What's happening in Idaho is a crucial moment for the virtual education movement and widespread acceptance of technology-centered education reform.
Earlier this year, Idaho Gov. Butch Otter signed three pieces of education reform legislation, called "Students Come First." The measures restrict some teacher collective bargaining, eliminates tenure and shifts funds from teacher salaries to technology upgrades and a merit-pay program. The overall goal is to bring a new focus on online learning.
It was a ugly, no holds bar fight to get the legislation to Otter's desk. Many compromises were made, leaving proponents and opponents of the reform package unhappy.
One of the proposals Idaho Superintendent of Instruction Tom Luna believed to be central to the reform package, requiring students to take at least four online classes in order to graduate from high school, had to be removed in order to get legislative approval for the plan.
But after Otter signed all three measures a new fight broke out. Luna announced he would go around the state legislature and ask the Idaho Board of Education to approve the online class graduation requirements.
What's more, opponents of the plan, opponents that included the Idaho Education Association, state's largest teachers union, started circulating petitions calling for a referendum to repeal the new laws to be placed on the 2012 ballot. The opponents also want to recall Luna.
Jack Jennings, executive director of the Center for Education Policy in Washington D.C. told the Associated Press that he is unaware of any other state where education reform opponents have launched a referendum campaign to repeal the laws.
In early June, opponents said they had turned in enough signatures to the Idaho Secretary of State to qualify the repeal measures for a statewide vote.
That's the situation Bush and Wise will find when they address the first meeting of the Idaho Education Technology Task Force. The 39-member task force, a statewide group whose creation was mandated as part of the "Students Come First" legislation. The group will investigate and make recommendations on how technology should be used in Idaho’s schools.
Bush and Wise are scheduled to speak on June 14 at 9 a.m. Mountain time (that's 8 a.m. on the Pacific Coast and 11 a.m. on the East Coast). The title of their talk is “Harnessing the Power of Technology for a 21st Century Education.”
This is not the first time the Digital Learning Now leadership has come to the aid of edtech-centered education reforms mired in controversy. Earlier this year, when it looked as if the Utah legislature was not going to approve expansion of online K-12 opportunities, the Digital Learning Now leadership went into action, shoring up support among lawmakers.
The upshot: The online expansion legislation was approved, signed into law by the Utah governor and now the state is one of the nation's virtual education leaders.
Click here for a link to a live stream of their talk.

Wednesday, June 8, 2011

Georgia

The fight to save Georgia's charters schools is a fight to save Georgia's virtual charter schools.
Look at the math.
About 15,500 Georgia students attend charter schools approved by the Georgia Charter Schools Commission. Approximately 10,000 of those students attend virtual charter schools.
In early May, the Georgia Supreme Court overturned a law that allowed the Georgia Charter Schools Commission to approve and fund charter schools over objections of local school boards.
This ruling left students enrolled in charter schools wondering if they would have a school to attend in the fall. It also put on the brakes on plans for opening of new charter and virtual charter schools.
Georgia Attorney General Sam Olens filed a request on behalf of Georgia Charter Schools Commission asking the Georgia Supreme Court to reconsider its ruling. Olens and others know that the court rarely grants such requests. The court did not issue an immediate decision on the late May filing.
Additionally, Georgia lawmakers are considering introducing a constitutional amendment to address the court's ruling.
Early in June, Odyssey School and Georgia Cyber Academy asked the state Board of Education to renew their charters. The two were approved by the Georgia Charter Schools Commission. If the schools get the go-ahead, they will merge.
The schools are the first of Georgia's 16 charter schools affected by the ruling to ask for a clarification of their status.
Opponents of the court's ruling say that it will limit school choice. "These charter schools provide our children with a high-quality education option that enables them to be true players in this fast-paced globally connected world we now live in. We cannot and will not allow parent choice to be taken away from Georgia families," Renee Lord, president of Georgia Families for Virtual Public Education wrote supporters.
"Luckily, we have many supportive leaders in the General Assembly who are already working diligently to find a swift and permanent solution. As our legislators explore every available option that can provide parents certainty for next year and beyond, we must continue to stay engaged in this process. We are confident that our elected officials can solve this problem if we remain a vocal and visible reminder of why they must act."

Friday, June 3, 2011

Florida

At long last, a level playing field for purveyors of online courses and for the educators, students, and parents who want access to them, has been created.
Gov. Rick Scott took the final step in creating an open marketplace for virtual education when he signed the "Digital Learning Now Act."
The measure mandates that every student, starting with incoming students beginning ninth grade in the fall of 2011, will need to take an online course in order to graduate from high school. Additionally, the new law allows creation of online-based charter schools.
Before Scott signed the Digital Learning Now Act into law, there were restrictions on the full-time participation of elementary students in online learning. What's more, Florida students could only take classes directly from Florida Virtual School or its local franchises.
Now, students in K-12 can take online courses. The law also makes it easier for virtual schools to set up in Florida.
Opponents of the measure worry that virtual learning providers would not have to hire teachers with the same qualifications as public schools. Additionally, some Florida school officials fear that the virtual learning providers would not have to teach the same curriculum or meet the same standards as traditional public schools.
Another concern the new law raises is about the fate of the Florida Virtual School (FLVS). Currently virtual education in Florida is provided by the public Florida Virtual School, which offers middle and high school classes, and six private vendors that districts can contract with. Districts also can create their own virtual programs. Students must go through the district to sign up for the classes. The proposal creates competition for the Florida Virtual School, and at the same time, requires it to offer full-time classes from K-12 . The new lase also allows students to sign up directly with virtual education vendors approved by the state education department.
Julie Young, founders and CEO of the Florida Virtual Schools, has said that competition will make every online provider better and is not worry about the impact the Digital Learning Now Act will have on the Florida Virtual School.
"We feel like that every program is different and has its own personality, and parents and students will choose what’s best for them,” Young said, adding she thought the measure "was good."
The new law directs the Florida Department of Education to expand online learning options and assist school districts in expanding their virtual education programs. This includes:
-- Allowing full-time, online school for kindergarten through high school.
-- Allowing home-schooled children to take online classes without previously attending a Florida public school.
-- Opening the door for private companies to set up virtual schools. That provision would also apply to charter schools, which are publicly funded but privately run.
The new law also impacts online teachers. Florida Virtual School teachers, were required to hold Flordia teaching credentials and, unless they had a special exemption, live in the state. Currently, FLVS employs 1,000 teachers certified in Florida. All but about 50 live in the state, Holly Sagues, FLVS's strategist and policy officer, told the Tampa Tribune.
Now, virtual school providers approved by the state education department would no longer have to be located in Florida. Teachers could direct classes from anywhere in the world, as long as they are certified by Florida, another state, or a national board.

Thursday, May 26, 2011

Washington

The forlorn note on the Facebook page of Washington Families for Online Learning said it all. "We lost. What now?"
The tears are over a hard-fought battle to prevent the Washington legislature from approving a two-year budget that included a 20% cut in Alternative Learning Experience (ALE) programs. In its final version, ESHB 2065 cut 15% from ALE programs and instructed the
Office of the Superintendent of Public Instruction to figure how to make the cuts. Gov. Christine Gregoire is expected to sign the bill.
According to virtual education proponents, this slash in funding would likely to shut down many, if not most, ALE programs – including the online schools.
"Not enough legislators have strong enough connections to our families and online public school programs to protect us from funding cuts," according to the note posted on the website of the Washington Families for Online Learning.
"We really need to ramp up our involvement is to engage legislators directly with our families and our online programs. Some legislators understand. Most do not," the Families for Online Learning post added.

Tuesday, May 17, 2011

Georgia

A ruling by the Georgia Supreme Court has sent a chill through supporters of the state's virtual charter schools.
In a 4-3 decision, the court struck down a law empowering the Georgia Charter Schools Commission to approve and finance charter schools. The commission had the power to create charters even if local school boards objected.
Virtual education movement supporters say this may be the death knell of virtual charters in the state.
Georgia has a virtual charter school and several more in the pipeline. In 2010, after approving two virtual charter schools, but not providing per pupil funding at a level many considered needed to make the schools viable, the charter commission increased the allocated for each student. This move was hailed by the virtual education community as a victory in making sure virtual schools receive appropriate funding.
Now, with the recent court ruling, Georgia virtual school community is at a loss.
In a post titled, "Supreme Court Ruling Puts Children's Futures at Risk," the Georgia Families for Public Education said this:
"The Georgia Supreme Court ruled that state authorized charter schools are not special schools and the state does not have the authority to create them in the first place.
"Georgia's online public schools, like Georgia Cyber Academy and Georgia Connections Academy are not part of this case. Still, our team will examine to see if this judgment even applies to our online public charter schools (for example, Georgia Virtual Academy, the online extension of Odyssey Charter School, Kaplan Academy of Georgia, and Provost Academy of Georgia, both approved in 2010, but embroiled in funding controversy) and work closely with the Attorney General and our own counsel to ensure the education of our children is met to the highest standards."
The National Coalition for Public School Options said the ruling was, "a victory for educrats who care more about money and control, and less about the needs of students. School districts made the decision to go after charter schools only after the state decided that school funds should follow the student. School funding was not an issue for the school districts previously when they collected funding for students who didn't attend their school.
"Rather," the coalition statement continued, "than focusing on bettering schools and offering services that parents and students need, school districts would rather maintain "status quo" and attack those that offer families innovation and options."
A rally, organized by the Georgia Charter Schools Association, to protest the decision was scheduled to be held on May 17 in front of the Georgia State Capitol.

Thursday, April 28, 2011

Michigan

"Any Time, Any Place, Any Way, Any Pace." That's the goal of the online learning part of Michigan Gov. Rick Snyder's education reform proposal.
"This plan is about moving away from the outdated model of the past and giving teachers and students the tools they need to succeed in the future." Snyder said. "We have to start looking at students as individuals with different abilities that need to be taken into account, but also as individuals with unlimited potential to achieve."
Virtual education movement supporters hailed Snyder's speech, adding that this is the first step toward keeping campaign promises to expand education technology in grades K-12.
To help move the state's schools toward a 21st century model, Snyder wants to "give students more opportunities to participate in dual enrollment, blended learning and online education opportunities."
He also would like to see changes in seat time regulation and "more flexibility when it comes to instruction and traditional configurations of classrooms."
Michigan has a long and proven track record when it comes to online learning. In 2006, Michigan was the first state to require that students have "online learning experience" in order to graduate from high school. Michigan has a state-led virtual school, the Michigan
Virtual School. In fall 2010, the state's first virtual charter school opened. The Michigan Virtual Charter Academy, operated by K-12 Inc. It launched with a curriculum geared for high school dropouts ages 17 to 21.
A 2011 report, Virtual Learning in Michigan Schools, the Mackinac Center for Public Policy congratulated the state on its online education policies and added, "from a policy perspective, online learning also promises something relatively rare in the long history of taxpayer-funded K-12 public instruction: providing the same or better service at a lower cost."
Education technology was only a part of a multi-layered reform package Snyder outlined in a Detroit speech. Among his proposals are major reforms to teacher tenure and pay as well as changes to early childhood education, a loosening of some limits on charter schools in the
state and expansion of the state's schools of choice program.
Everyone is not enthused by Snyder's proposal. According to AnnArbor.com, the Michigan Education Association, the state's largest teachers union, is planning to protest Snyder's appearance at the University of Michigan, where is is scheduled to give the commencement address.

Friday, April 22, 2011

Oregon

It has been a bruising week in the fight over the future of online schools in Oregon.
The controversy is over two bills, Senate Bill 927 and House Bill 2301, which would have significant impact on K-12 online opportunities if either becomes law.
Here's how Liberating Learning blog contributor Christina Martin, a policy analyst with the Cascade Policy Institute in Portland sees it.
"Senate Bill 927, would essentially destroy Oregon’s virtual charter schools," Martin writes. The brainchild of the Oregon Education Association, Senate Bill 927, would place online charters in a similar category as alternative schools. What's more, the measure would create the "Oregon Option Consortium" which would become the agency to provide K-12 online courses.
House Bill 2301, Martin says, "some great elements that would increase online opportunities for kids. But it also has problems, including decreasing the funding that follows online charter students and capping the number of kids from each district who may freely transfer to online charter schools without district permission."
Parents of students attending virtual l classes have written passionately about the legislation. Martin issued a call for virtual school supporters to let their legislators know their thoughts about the bills.
There was little movement on both measures, even though hearings on both bills were held.
Stay tuned. This battle is just beginning.

Monday, April 18, 2011

Idaho

Some thought that the donnybrook that broke out earlier this year over Idaho schools chief Tom Luna's education reform package, also known as "Students Come First," was over. Idaho's Gov. Butch Otter signed the three-pieced package into law. Luna's original proposal of requiring high school grads to successfully complete eight online course, been beaten down to four course, and finally revised even further downward to zero. The final version of the new law called the state Board of Education to create "digital citizenship standards," and to consider adding online courses as a graduation requirement for the class of 2016. But in an April 5 New York Times story, Luna indicated that this summer he would go to the state Board of Education with a new proposal to make taking four online courses be mandatory for the class of 2016. Luna believes that he will be more successful in getting state board backing for this plan because he has more support on the board."I have no doubt we'll get a robust rule through them" Luna told The Times. Luna may not have doubts, but it looks as if he will have another fight on his hands.
Opponents of the graduation requirement say that not all students have access to the Internet when they are away from school. Additionally, they claim, because of potential funding and staffing cuts, schools may not be able to afford laptops, software and other tech-related materials for students and faculty.
Because of new rules on how the state will fund schools, schools with students who take one or more online courses away from the traditional campus will not get full funding for the student. This has led some to call for the board to hold public hearings on any online course graduation requirements. This isn't all that Luna will be busy with. Petitions are now circulating throughout the state to recall Luna and to place a referendum of the November 2012 ballot on his reform plan. To place a referendum on the November 2012 ballot, petitioners must collect 47,432 signatures from registered voters. The recall petition would require more than 158,000 signatures. That would force an election. In order to remove Luna, at least 268,853 votes would be required -- one more than he received in November 2010. The Idaho Education Association's delegate assembly voted to endorse the referendum drive.