Another Pennsylvania state legislator stepped into the arena with a plan to reconstruct the way the state funds charter and cyber charter schools.
The new bill arrives at a time when a Stanford University study raises questions about the state's charter schools and when a growing number of Pennsylvania school districts, many claiming they are short-changed by the state when their students attend cyber charter schools, are scrambling to launch their own cyber charters by fall.
Earlier this week, Rep. James Roebuck, the Democratic chairman of the Pennsylvania House Education Committee, introduced a bill that would shift the cost of underwriting charter and cyber charter students away from the districts to the state.
Roebuck told a McClatchy-Tribune reporter that his bill would the measure, which would require the state to pay tuition for Pennsylvania's 50,000 charter and cyber charter students, could save districts $187 million.
This is not the first measure introduced this year to find a new funding solution. Other bills have been introduced only to languish in the Pennsylvania legislature. Lawmakers are feeling heat to do something about the funding situation because late in 2010, state Auditor Gen. Jack Wagner called for a moratorium on creation any new new charter or cyber charters in the state because , the current funding system has serious inequities in how tax money is used to finance these public school alternatives.
In addition to changing the way charter and cyber charter schools are funded, the Roebuck bill would create an Office of Charter and Cyber Charter Schools within the Department of Education, which would oversee these schools. The schools would also be required to meet
academic standards or lose their charters.
The quality of education provided by Pennsylvania's charter and cyber charters was called into question by a study by Stanford University's Center for Research on Education Outcomes (CREDO).
The report, Charter School Performance in Pennsylvania, showed mixed results in math and reading, with all cyber charter students lagging their counterparts in public schools.
"Elementary school students enrolled in charter schools outperformed their peers in traditional public schools in both math and reading, while those enrolled in middle and multilevel charter schools performed worse in both subjects than their peers at traditional public schools," the report says.
A poor showing by the state's online charter schools dragged down the overall charter school numbers.
Students at cyber charters, who accounted for 30% of the charter students covered by the study, performed significantly worse than students at public schools, the study said.
Belief that local school districts can do a better job than the current cyber charters, coupled with a desire to capture more state education money, may be why Pennsylvania school districts from Bensalem to Reading want to start their own cyber charter schools.
Because districts must pay the tuition for students within their borders who attend charter and cyber charter schools elsewhere, opening a cyber school to retain students or lure them back is in the districts' financial interest.
For each child enrolled in a cyber charter school, the district receives just 20% of the state funding it would receive for a student attending a traditional public school.
"By setting up their own cyber schools, districts are actually able to save money," Steve Robinson, a spokesman for the Pennsylvania School Boards Association, told a McClatchy Tribune reporter.
No comments:
Post a Comment