Thursday, December 29, 2011
Michigan
It looks as if a decision on lifting the cap on cyber schools in Michigan will happen sometime in 2012.
Some thought that SB 619 would be approved and signed into law by the end of 2011. That's what happened with it's companion bill, SB 618, which lifted the cap on the number of charter schools.
But as the old year moved to a close, SB 619, was stalled in the the Michigan House education committee and isn't expected to be voted on until the new year.
The measure has already been approved by the Michigan Senate.
Currently, there are two cyber schools in Michigan with an enrollment of 400 students each. Should the bill pass, the cap on the number of schools would be lifted, and the 400 student per school enrollment cap would be increased to 1,000.
Other provisions in the bill include:
--Eliminating the requirement that cyber school students previously have been enrolled in a public school.
--Requiring cyber school operators to demonstrate experience delivering a program that improves student academic achievement. Currently, the state requires the applicant demonstrate experience in serving urban and at-risk student populations through an educational model involving a significant cyber component.
Proponents of SB 619 say the bill believe it offers more options to students, as well as ties in strong use of technology.
State Representative Tom McMillin, who chairs the House Education Committee, told Michigan Public Radio that he and many other lawmakers are impressed with the ability of cyber schools to help kids who struggle in traditional public schools, or drop out.
"It has blown us away, I mean it’s extremely impressive. I think it’s going to be, once people see what it’s producing, what the results are, they get all excited about it,” McMillan said.
Opponents to the measure say the cyber schools lack accountability and oversight and question the funding method.
A post on "Blogging for Michigan" stated that, "The Michigan Virtual Charter Academy that made a presentation at the Dec. 6 House committee meeting failed to meet Adequate Yearly Progress (AYP) during their one year of operation, and that was not brought out. Apparently, the school only tested less than 80 percent of their students instead of the required 95 percent. That requirement is in place so a school cannot cherry pick and only have their best students take the Michigan Educational Assessment Program test (MEAP)."
"This bill, along with Senate Bill 618 that lifts the cap on charter schools, is just a thinly disguised attempt to privatize public education and bust teacher unions," the post continued.
Michigan Republicans leaders in the GOP-dominated legislature say they want to allow more K-12 cyber schools. GOP Gov. Rick Scott says he will sign any bill lifting the cap into law. But everything is on hold until the new year.
Friday, December 9, 2011
California
A coalition of California school districts, county offices of education and statewide education associations are taking a new tact when it comes to the battle over expansion of K-12 online learning.
This could be one of the first volleys in a change of strategy that is starting to gain adherents among teachers unions and in other parts of the education establishment.
These groups no longer want to be seen as just saying no to digital learning initiatives. Instead, they are starting to develop their own criteria for implementation of digital learning and creation of virtual charter and virtual schools. In some cases, the education establishment's methods are seen as delaying tactics.
In California, an organization that calls itself the "K-12 Education Management Group" has issued a set of seven principles it says are needed for a statewide digital learning policy can be put into place.
"The Department of Education, Department of Finance and key legislative staffers are skeptical that if the kid's not in a room with a teacher, they're not sure what level of learning is actually going on. We're working on language … to reach some kind of harmony in the issue," Jeff Frost, a lobbyist for several education organizations and school districts involved in K-12 Education Management Group, told Joanna Lin of California Watch.
That language, Frost said, will support the notion that Average Daily Attendance (ADA) can be calculated based on student work.
"Whether they're in the virtual school's learning center or whether they're at home with their mom looking over their shoulder or whether they're in the public library – if they're there working, that's the same as a kid who showed up in school," he added.
Among the principles listed in the group's "Statement of Principles" are "online learning must be held to the same standards as traditional classroom-based education;" "a funding mechanism that is appropriate for online learning should be adopted and equal access must be provided for all of California's six million students;" and "school districts should have flexibility in how online programs are implemented."
Monday, December 5, 2011
Michigan
This week, Michigan legislators my take the long-awaited steps to lifting caps on the number of cyber schools in the state.
SB 619, the cyber school bill, is part of an education reform package making its way through the Michigan legislature. A bill that would lift the cap on creation of charter schools was approved by the Michigan House the week of Nov. 28.
The charter school and the cyber school measures are parent of the "Parental Empowerment Package." Other measures include a bill that would would allow public schools to be converted to charter schools. That bill has been introduced in the Michigan Senate, but hasn't been brought to a full vote. Another bill that would change the criteria for state education aid for "instruction of nonpublic students by public schools" has been approved by the state Senate, but not by the House.
All the bills in the package must be approved in order for any of the measures to become law.
There are currently two cyber schools in Michigan serving approximately 400 students.
Proponents of SB 619 say more cyber schools will provide more choices to Michigan parents looking for the best educational opportunities for their children.
"Cyber schools are another option we have in reforming our education system in Michigan so that we are meeting the varied needs of all of our students,” said State. Sen. Patrick Colbeck, a sponsor of the bill. “These schools provide a free, public education to students that can be tailored to address each child’s strengths and weaknesses while providing increased one-on-one communication with a teacher.”
Opponents want to wait for more information on the effectiveness of the state's two cyber schools. At an earlier hearing on the measure, State Sen. Hoon-Yung Hopgood wondered why there wasn’t even a baseline report for legislators to key on before a vote is taken on SB 619.
“In fact, we are not even looking at the reports that we demand for these cyber schools at their outset," Hopgood said. "The reason we know that we haven’t looked at these reports is because they are not due yet, and they are not available. Why aren’t we using the best information that we can? Why aren’t we being more transparent? Why aren’t we making sure that there are proper and thorough audits done so we know where the money is going?”
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)