The Arizona legislature is turning its attention to the state's booming K-12 online learning environment.
And, it seems, no matter what side of the online learning debate you are on, clarifying funding and increasing accountability is a good direction to take.
Of course, the devil is in the details.
There are several bills currently winding their way through the legislature. Senate Bill 1259 would allow online providers to earn more state funding if students finish courses and demonstrate, on state-approved tests, that they have mastered the content. The measure would also create a separate funding option from that of the current Arizona Online Instruction Program.
House Bill 2260 could make it easier for district-school students to take more online courses from the district or an outside school. One provision in the bill would require districts to accept credits from all other state-approved online courses.
A third bill, SB 1463, would require online schools to supervise final exams, which some educators believe would help deter cheating. Currently, Arizona requires only that statewide assessments, such as the Arizona's Instrument to Measure Standards test, be given in person.
Some say a 2011 Arizona Republic investigative series on online education for the legislative attention. The series claimed that Arizona's online K-12 programs have relatively lax oversight and limited disclosure of information and argued that there were few or no requirements for how schools monitor their tests. The risks, the series charged, of cheating in the largest online schools were high.
Despite such problems and a critical state audit in 2007, according to the Republic's reporting, the state Legislature in 2009 removed caps on the number of online schools allowed to operate.
Since removal of the enrollment cap, the number of district and charter online schools has jumped from 14 to 66 schools. Nearly 36,000 students took one or more online classes in the 2010-11 school year.
Even if the legislation is a product of its series, the Republic reports, it is unclear which of the bills, if any, will become law.
Proponents of the measures, such as Jonathan Butcher, education director at the Arizona-based Goldwater Institute, say much of the legislation is the “type of leg-up the virtual world needs to be the most effective."
Butcher added that said he supports innovative practices that provide a la carte education, and that online schools help increase school choice by creating innovative avenues for students to utilize several different school options simultaneously.
Opponents to the measures, and to SB 1259 particularly, criticized it as too soft, saying it appeared to have "symbolic" accountability provisions added to help get it through the legislature. Some online learning backers say in-person supervision of students taking statewide exams online will be burdensome to students who live in rural areas.
The Arizona School Boards Association hasn't taken a position on the bills, but its lobbyist, Janice Palmer, told the Arizona Republic that the group supports bringing more accountability to online courses and making sure students are learning.
No comments:
Post a Comment